Skip to Content

Can girls outrun boys?

The question of whether girls can outrun boys has long been a topic of debate. Historically, boys have been thought to have an advantage in running speed and endurance. However, in recent years, as more girls have started participating in competitive running, the answer has become less clear.

What the Science Says

Scientifically speaking, the main factors that impact running speed and endurance are muscle mass, aerobic capacity, and biomechanics. Here’s a quick look at what the research shows about how boys and girls compare:

  • Muscle mass – On average, boys have more muscle mass than girls, especially in the upper body. Greater muscle mass can translate into more power and speed.
  • Aerobic capacity – Maximum oxygen uptake (VO2 max), which measures aerobic fitness, is typically 10-15% higher in adolescent boys than girls. A high VO2 max corresponds to better endurance.
  • Biomechanics – Boys tend to have greater stride lengths than girls, which can make them faster runners. However, proper running form and biomechanics can be developed with training.

While boys may have some natural advantages, these gender differences tend to decrease with age. And with proper training, girls can definitely narrow the gap.

How Girls and Boys Compare in Running Events

When looking at running records and performances, male athletes do tend to run faster than female athletes, on average. Here’s how the genders stack up:

Distance Male World Record Female World Record
100m 9.58s (Usain Bolt) 10.49s (Florence Griffith Joyner)
200m 19.19s (Usain Bolt) 21.34s (Florence Griffith Joyner)
400m 43.03s (Wayde van Niekerk) 47.60s (Marita Koch)
800m 1:40.91 (David Rudisha) 1:53.28 (Jarmila Kratochvilova)
1500m 3:26.00 (Hicham El Guerrouj) 3:50.07 (Genzebe Dibaba)
1 mile 3:43.13 (Hicham El Guerrouj) 4:12.56 (Svetlana Masterkova)
5K 12:37.35 (Kenenisa Bekele) 14:11.15 (Tirunesh Dibaba)
10K 26:17.53 (Kenenisa Bekele) 29:17.45 (Almaz Ayana)
Marathon 2:01:39 (Eliud Kipchoge) 2:14:04 (Brigid Kosgei)

As the data shows, male runners are faster than females from sprints to long distance running. The gap is smallest for the marathon, where the top women are only about 10-12% slower than the top men. But for shorter distances like the 100m, the difference widens to around 15-16%.

What Accounts for the Gender Differences?

The physiological advantages held by male runners, such as greater muscle mass and aerobic capacity, are likely responsible for much of this disparity. Social and cultural factors that lead to more male participation in running sports probably also play a role.

However, while boys may have an edge in speed, the gap is slowly closing as more girls begin competing in running. Factors like nutrition, training, coaching and equipment access can allow female runners to maximize their potential and narrow gender performance gaps.

How Boys and Girls Compare at Different Ages

Gender differences in running performance are highly dependent on age. During childhood, boys and girls develop at similar rates and have comparable running abilities. But gender gaps emerge as children get older.

Here’s an overview of how boys and girls tend to compare at different ages:

Ages 6-8

At young ages, there is very little difference between boys and girls in running skill or speed. Both genders are developing strength, endurance, motor skills and coordination. Gender gaps in cardiovascular fitness are also minimal in early childhood.

Ages 9-12

As children approach puberty, small gender differences in running emerge. Boys begin to gain advantages in speed, which may be related to increased muscle mass or biomechanical factors. However, with training, talented young female runners can still match or outperform boys.

Ages 13-18

This age range sees the most divergence between male and female runners. The performance gap widens as boys go through puberty and experience rapid increases in height, weight and muscle mass. Aerobic capacity also increases more quickly in adolescent boys than girls.

While boys hold an edge in speed events, well-trained teenage girls can close the gap through dedicated training. And some studies have found teenage girls may have advantages in very long distance running due to body fat percentage.

Ages 18+

After puberty, gender differences in running ability stabilize. Elite adult female runners are typically 10-15% slower over short and middle distance events. The gap narrows slightly for marathon distances. But through specialized training, female runners can maximize speed and endurance.

Overall, the gender divide is most pronounced during the adolescent growth spurt. But a combination of physiological and cultural factors contribute to superior male running performances across all age groups.

Noteworthy Race Examples

While male runners hold the overall speed advantage, there are still examples of young female runners outpacing male peers. Here are some noteworthy races where girls beat the boys:

Age 13 – Mary Cain

In 2009, middle schooler Mary Cain finished 2nd in the 3,000m event at the National Outdoor Track Championships – beating all female and male competitors in her age group. She ran 9:38.68, a time that would have won the boy’s 14 and under category.

Age 14 – Alexa Efraimson

In 2013, Alexa Efraimson set national records in the 1500m and mile races for 14-year-old girls. Her mile time of 4:32.15 was nearly 10 seconds faster than the national record for 14-year-old boys.

Age 17 – Alana Hadley

At the 2016 Virginia State Indoor Track Championships, Alana Hadley won the 55-meter hurdles event in a photo finish against the boys. Her time of 7.82 seconds edged the 7.84 seconds run by a male competitor.

While these examples are rare, they do demonstrate that sufficiently talented and trained female runners can outpace male peers under the right circumstances. Most experts believe physiological advantages give boys an edge. But work ethic and coaching can still allow some girls to excel.

The Verdict

Based on the overall body of evidence, it appears that male runners do possess real physiological advantages in speed, endurance and running economy. The gender gap emerges in adolescence and expands through puberty.

However, female runners can overcome some of these handicaps through proper training and maximizing efficiency. While gender records and results show that boys and men run faster on average, some girls and women have been able to beat male runners of the same age through dedication.

So can girls outrun boys? The science leans toward “no” looking at whole populations. But plenty of individual examples prove that some determined girls certainly can beat the odds.

Conclusion

While male runners tend to perform better statistically, female runners are closing the gender gap. With access to training and coaching, talented and committed girls can outpace male peers. But physiological factors give boys advantages, especially from puberty onward. In the end, running ability comes down to individual effort as much as gender attributes. And examples of girls beating boys demonstrate running success is about more than just natural talent.