Skip to Content

Can I use condensed milk instead of sugar?

Using condensed milk in place of regular sugar is a common baking substitution. Condensed milk contains a large amount of sugar, so it can be used to sweeten and add texture to recipes. There are some important considerations when substituting condensed milk for granulated sugar in order to achieve the best results.

The difference between condensed milk and sugar

Condensed milk is milk that has been reduced by heating it with sugar until it reaches a thick, syrupy texture. About 40-45% of condensed milk is sugar. The rest is milk solids and water. On the other hand, granulated white sugar contains sucrose with no water content.

Here are some key differences between condensed milk and granulated sugar:

  • Condensed milk is thicker, stickier, and more viscous than granulated sugar.
  • Condensed milk is sweeter than sugar by volume – a smaller amount of condensed milk is needed to achieve the same level of sweetness.
  • Condensed milk contributes a caramel/toffee flavor while sugar has a neutral taste.
  • Condensed milk browns faster than granulated sugar when heated.
  • Condensed milk adds moisture to baked goods.

Substitution ratio for condensed milk and sugar

When substituting condensed milk for sugar in recipes, keep in mind that condensed milk is much sweeter due to its high sugar content. Many bakers recommend using half the amount of condensed milk as the amount of sugar called for in the recipe.

For example, if a recipe calls for 1 cup of granulated sugar, use 1/2 cup condensed milk. The exact substitution ratio can vary based on personal taste preference for sweetness and the particular recipe, but a 1:2 ratio is a safe starting point.

How to substitute condensed milk for sugar in recipes

Here are some tips for substituting condensed milk for sugar successfully:

  • Reduce the amount of condensed milk to half the amount of sugar called for. You can adjust to taste after testing a recipe.
  • Because condensed milk adds moisture, you may need to reduce other wet ingredients slightly.
  • Don’t substitute condensed milk for sugar in recipes with a delicate texture, like meringues or some cakes. The moisture can make them gummy.
  • Condensed milk browns faster than white sugar. Reduce oven temperature by 25°F to prevent over-browning if baking.
  • Stir the condensed milk well before using to incorporate any separation.
  • In recipes without other dairy, like cookies, you can use condensed milk straight from the can.
  • In recipes with water, milk, buttermilk, or other liquids, dilute the condensed milk first before adding.

Baking recipes that work well with condensed milk

Condensed milk can be used successfully in a variety of baking recipes. Here are some recipes where substituting condensed milk for sugar produces delicious results:

  • Cakes and cupcakes – Devil’s food, red velvet, carrot, banana, and other moist cakes turn out well with condensed milk. Reduce other liquids.
  • Cookies – Chewy chocolate chip, oatmeal, and peanut butter cookies can be made with condensed milk.
  • Brownies and blondies – Fudgy, gooey brownies are a perfect match for condensed milk. Also try in blondies.
  • Pie fillings and custards – Condensed milk thickens up pumpkin, lemon, chocolate, and custard pies nicely.
  • Frostings and sauces – Try using condensed milk for creamy homemade frostings, caramel sauce, and more.
  • Breakfast baked goods – Condensed milk works in moist muffins, quick breads like banana, and even pancake recipes.

Start by using condensed milk in small batch recipes like a 9×13 pan of brownies to test it out before making large cakes or batches of cookies. Adjust the amount of condensed milk to get your ideal level of sweetness.

Advantages of substituting condensed milk for sugar

There are some benefits to using condensed milk rather than regular granulated sugar in baking:

  • Condensed milk adds moistness and richness to baked goods.
  • The caramelized, buttery flavor of condensed milk improves flavor in items like brownies.
  • Recipes made with condensed milk tend to stay fresh longer.
  • You may be able to reduce the amount of butter or oil in a recipe when using condensed milk.
  • Condensed milk is shelf-stable so convenient for baking if you run out of sugar.

The thick, smooth texture and boosted moisture content from the milk solids in condensed milk enhances the mouthfeel of many baked goods. The caramel notes pair especially well with chocolate. Using condensed milk can result in fudgier brownies, richer chocolate cake, and chewier cookies.

Potential disadvantages of substituting condensed milk

There are also some potential downsides to keep in mind when using condensed milk instead of sugar in recipes:

  • Condensed milk does not perform exactly the same as granulated sugar in baked goods. The final texture may differ.
  • Overuse of condensed milk can make some baked goods too dense or wet.
  • The sweetened condensed milk flavor may overwhelm more delicate recipes.
  • Recipes with condensed milk tend to brown faster so require vigilance when baking.
  • Condensed milk has a thicker, stickier texture than sugar that can make mixing and blending more difficult.

While condensed milk works as a substitute in many recipes, the end result is typically a moister, denser, and sweeter product. It is best for recipes where this effect complements the other ingredients. Condensed milk may not be ideal in recipes where you want a very light and airy texture.

Is unsweetened condensed milk an effective sugar substitute?

You can also find unsweetened condensed milk, which has the thick, creamy texture but no added sugar. However, unsweetened condensed milk is not an effective direct substitute for granulated sugar in recipes. Here’s why:

  • Unsweetened condensed milk does not provide the necessary sweetness.
  • The texture and moisture content still differ greatly from granulated sugar.
  • You would need to add your own sugar to unsweetened condensed milk to use it as a sugar substitute.

Unsweetened condensed milk can be used along with sugar to provide creaminess and body in some recipes like fudge or ice cream. But on its own, unsweetened condensed milk cannot effectively replace the sweetness, texture, moisture, and bulking ability of regular granulated sugar.

How does using condensed milk affect the nutrition of recipes?

Substituting condensed milk for sugar affects the nutrition profile of baked goods in a few key ways:

  • Higher calorie content – Condensed milk contains more calories per serving than granulated sugar.
  • More fat and saturated fat from the milk content.
  • Condensed milk has lactose while sugar is lactose-free.
  • Often provides a boost in protein when replacing sugar.
  • Condensed milk has some calcium and other minerals while sugar contains empty calories.

So condensed milk adds more calories, fat, and some nutrients compared to recipes made strictly with sugar. Recipes made with condensed milk are often still high in sugar since condensed milk is nearly half sugar.

If trying to reduce the sugar and calorie content of a recipe, condensed milk would not be the best option. You could use a low-calorie granulated sugar substitute instead. But if you don’t mind the extra calories, the creaminess of condensed milk can enhance flavor and texture.

Other substitutes for sugar in baking

In addition to condensed milk, there are some other substitutes you can use in place of granulated sugar in recipes:

  • Honey – Replace up to half the sugar with honey. Reduce liquids to account for the added moisture.
  • Maple syrup – Use 2/3 cup of maple syrup for every 1 cup of sugar. Reduce liquids and lower oven temp since it burns easily.
  • Fruit juice or puree – Applesauce and mashed bananas work well in things like muffins and cakes.
  • Low-calorie sweeteners – Sugar substitutes like stevia, erythritol, and sucralose.

Experiment with different sugar substitutes to find the right option for your specific recipe. Factors like moisture content, texture, flavor, and nutrition profile should guide your choice.

Conclusion

Condensed milk can effectively substitute for granulated sugar in many baking recipes when used carefully. Reduce the amount of condensed milk to half the amount of sugar called for. The rich caramel flavor and moisture of condensed milk pairs particularly well in brownies, chocolate cookies, and cupcakes. Avoid over-sweetening recipes and watch closely when baking to prevent burning. While condensed milk contains more calories than sugar, it can improve flavor and texture in the right recipes.