Skip to Content

Can Ring camera be subpoenaed?

Home security cameras like Ring are becoming increasingly popular, with millions of households now having cameras installed. With this rise in popularity, questions have emerged around the legal implications of home security camera footage, specifically whether it can be subpoenaed as evidence in court cases.

What is a Subpoena?

A subpoena is a legal document issued by a court that compels an individual or organization to provide specific evidence or testimony. Subpoenas are commonly used by lawyers during the discovery process of a legal case to obtain information from third parties relevant to the case.

There are generally two types of subpoenas:

  • Subpoena duces tecum – requires a person or organization to produce physical evidence, such as documents or recordings
  • Subpoena ad testificandum – requires a person to testify as a witness

When it comes to home security footage, a subpoena duces tecum would typically be issued to obtain camera recordings that may contain evidence about a legal case.

Can My Ring Camera Footage Be Subpoenaed?

In short – yes, Ring camera footage can be subpoenaed by law enforcement or lawyers under the right circumstances. However, there are specific requirements and procedures that must be followed.

According to Ring’s privacy policy, they will share users’ personal information, including videos, when compelled by government agencies and law enforcement. This means police could subpoena footage directly from Ring if they have a search warrant or court order. Ring states they will notify users of requests for video footage unless prohibited by law.

Lawyers can also subpoena Ring footage by sending a subpoena request directly to the Ring user. The user would then be legally required to provide relevant footage they have access to. Failure to comply could result in being held in contempt of court.

When Can Ring Camera Footage Be Subpoenaed?

There are specific legal requirements that must be met for Ring footage to be subpoenaed:

  • The footage must be relevant to an active legal case or criminal investigation.
  • The request must come from law enforcement with a valid warrant or court order, or from the lawyer of the case by subpoena.
  • The footage requested must be reasonable in scope and specific in detail.

Law enforcement or lawyers cannot simply demand all footage captured by a Ring camera – they must demonstrate the relevance of specific footage to the particular legal matter.

What Kind of Cases Could Lead to a Subpoena?

Some examples of legal cases where Ring camera footage may be subpoenaed as evidence include:

  • Criminal cases – Footage capturing a crime, criminal suspect or other details relevant to a police investigation.
  • Personal injury lawsuits – Video showing an accident or injury incident, such as slip-and-fall.
  • Property damage claims – Vandalism, theft or other property damage occurring within view of the camera.
  • Family legal matters – Relevant footage for divorce proceedings, child custody cases, etc.
  • Neighbor disputes – Boundary disagreements, noise complaints, trespassing disputes, etc.

However, the video must be specifically relevant to the particulars of the case at hand to be subpoenaed.

What Are the Requirements for Complying with a Subpoena?

If you receive a valid subpoena requesting Ring footage, there are certain legal requirements for complying:

  • You must provide the footage requested by the specified date, in the correct format.
  • You should not alter, modify or edit the footage – it must be provided as the original file.
  • You can object to the subpoena if you believe the request is unreasonable, irrelevant to the case, or privileged.
  • If you fail to respond to the subpoena, you could face being held in contempt of court.

While the footage belongs to you, once a valid subpoena has been issued you are legally obligated to provide the requested video or face penalties from the court.

What Footage is Protecting from Disclosure?

While most Ring footage could potentially be subpoenaed, there are certain types of video protected from disclosure:

  • Attorney-client privileged communications – Any conversations with your attorney captured on video.
  • Medical privacy – Video showing medical treatments, procedures or other protected health details.
  • Financial information – Any private financial documents or information captured by the camera.
  • Minor children – In some cases, video of minor children may be protected.

You may be able to contest the subpoena if it asks for footage you believe should be kept confidential for legal reasons.

Can Ring Footage Be Subpoenaed for a Divorce?

Ring camera footage is increasingly being subpoenaed for use as evidence in divorce and child custody proceedings. Video capturing events related to the divorce may be requested, such as:

  • Footage showing abuse, domestic violence or altercations between spouses.
  • Video proving infidelity or extramarital affairs.
  • Footage demonstrating fitness as a parent, such as playing with children.
  • Video showing a spouse’s activities and schedule.

Ring cameras could capture incriminating video directly relevant to determining outcomes in a divorce or child custody case. However, there are limits on what can legally be disclosed – privileged and private footage is still protected in divorce proceedings.

Can You Delete Footage Before It’s Subpoenaed?

Deleting footage that you know may be subject to a subpoena can amount to destruction of evidence. This could result in criminal charges or civil penalties, including:

  • Obstruction of justice
  • Tampering with evidence
  • Contempt of court
  • Spoliation – intentional destruction of evidence

You have a duty to preserve relevant evidence if you reasonably expect it to be requested or subpoenaed. Deleting specific footage after receiving notice of legal proceedings can have severe consequences.

Can Police Obtain Ring Footage Without a Subpoena?

Ring has partnerships with many police departments across the US to facilitate video requests. Through the ‘Neighbors’ portal, police can post video requests for users in a specific area. If users opt-in, they can voluntarily share footage with law enforcement.

However, users are not obligated to share through the Neighbors portal. Police still require a valid subpoena or warrant to compel the release of footage without the owner’s consent.

How to Respond to a Subpoena for Ring Camera Footage

If you receive a subpoena for your Ring footage, here are important steps to take:

  1. Carefully review the subpoena – Make sure it is valid and signed by the court.
  2. Identify the specific footage requested – Review your Ring recordings.
  3. Consult an attorney if needed – They can advise if the subpoena is reasonable and enforceable.
  4. Preserve the requested video – Save it so it is not deleted or altered.
  5. Formally respond – State whether you will comply or object to the subpoena.
  6. Send the footage by the deadline – In the format and manner specified.

Complying fully and on-time is critical, as failure to do so can result in court sanctions.

Privacy Concerns Around Law Enforcement Access to Footage

While Ring cameras provide security for homeowners, consumer advocacy groups have raised privacy concerns around law enforcement access. These include:

  • Mass surveillance – Large networks of home security cameras effectively expand police surveillance capabilities.
  • Warrantless access – Privacy advocates argue footage should only be obtained with a warrant.
  • User consent – Users may feel pressured to share footage when police request access.
  • Data breaches – Hackers or other unauthorized access of sensitive footage data.

However, Ring states they will only release user data to police when compelled by a valid legal demand or with express user consent. Still, the growing web of home surveillance cameras presents new privacy implications.

Frequently Asked Questions

How far back can Ring footage be subpoenaed?

Most Ring cameras store recordings for a limited lookback period before overwriting old footage. This ranges from days to weeks depending on subscription plan. Footage older than the retention period cannot be obtained by subpoena or warrant.

Does Ring notify you if police request your footage?

Yes, Ring states they will send a notification if law enforcement requests a user’s videos without their consent, unless prohibited by law.

Can police make you turn over your Ring recordings?

Not without a valid subpoena, court order or search warrant. Users have the right to decline voluntary police requests for access through Ring’s Neighbors portal.

Do you have to tell people they are being recorded by a Ring camera?

It depends. In public areas like streets and sidewalks, signage is not required. But recording identifiable audio in private settings may require notification or consent in certain states.

Conclusion

Ring doorbell cameras provide helpful home security, but also create new privacy considerations given the video evidence they capture. While this footage could be valuable in legal proceedings, there are constitutional protections and legal procedures police and lawyers must follow to lawfully obtain it.

Homeowners should be aware recordings could potentially be subject to subpoena, and exercise caution to only capture video relevant to their own property and perimeter. With proper use, Ring cameras can enhance home security without intruding into broader public spaces or compromising personal privacy rights.