Skip to Content

Can you mix root beer with milk?

Mixing root beer and milk is something some people enjoy, while others find the combination unappealing. There are a few factors to consider when deciding whether or not to mix these two beverages.

Taste

The main question around mixing root beer and milk is – how does it taste? The flavor profile of root beer combined with milk is interesting. Root beer has a sweet, sugary taste usually flavored with sassafras, vanilla, and spices like cinnamon. When mixed with milk, the tangy and creamy dairy notes interact with the sweetness and carbonation of the soda. Some people enjoy the interplay of flavors and find it reminiscent of a float. The creaminess of the milk balances out the bubbly soda. However, others find the taste unusual or unappealing, especially the aftertaste that can have a funny flavor from the reaction of the ingredients.

Overall, whether or not someone likes the taste of root beer mixed with milk is very subjective. Some people are put off by the idea of mixing soda and dairy, while others find it delicious. The best way to find out if you enjoy it is to try it yourself!

Nutrition

When assessing whether to mix root beer and milk nutritionally, there are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Calories – Root beer is high in sugar and calories, while milk provides protein, calcium, vitamin D, and other nutrients. The combination results in a higher calorie beverage.
  • Sugar content – Mixing sugary soda with milk further increases the overall sugar content. For those limiting added sugars, the combination may not be ideal.
  • Protein – Milk provides a good amount of protein, so the mixed drink does end up with more protein than soda alone.
  • Hydration – While milk provides hydration from its water content, root beer is not as hydrating due to its high sugar and carbonation.
  • Upset stomach – Some people may experience gastric discomfort from the milk and root beer mixture if they are sensitive to lactose or carbonation.

Overall, while milk adds some nutritional value compared to drinking root beer alone, the combination is higher in sugar, calories, and carbonation than plain milk. For those watching their sugar intake or calories, it may be best to avoid mixing the two together in large amounts.

Carbonation

Another consideration when mixing root beer and milk is the effect on the carbonation. Root beer is a carbonated soda, meaning it contains dissolved CO2 gas bubbles that provide its fizzy, bubbly texture. When root beer is mixed with milk, a few things can happen to the carbonation:

  • The carbonation may be partially lost, resulting in a less effervescent, flatter mixture.
  • The milk proteins and fat may suppress some of the carbonation release, making the drink seem less bubbly.
  • The carbonation may cause the milk to become foamy on the top.
  • Over time, the carbonation will dissipate as the gas bubbles escape from the mixture.

For those who really enjoy the sensation of highly carbonated soda, mixing it with milk does result in losing some of that mouthfeel and bubbles. Mixing a small amount with milk likely retains more carbonation, while making a larger batch may lead to a very foamy, less carbonated mixture. Overall, the root beer will lose some of its fizziness and bubbly carbonation from the reaction with the milk.

Curdling

There is also the possibility of curdling when root beer and milk are combined. Curdling occurs when the milk proteins (casein) become unstable and aggregate together, forming clumps or curds. A few factors that can contribute to milk curdling with root beer include:

  • Acidity – Root beer contains carbonic acid from the dissolved CO2, which lowers the pH. This acidity can destabilize milk proteins.
  • Sugar – High amounts of sugar from the root beer may impact the proteins in milk.
  • Temperature – Very cold temperatures from chilled root beer or ice cream can cause curdling.
  • Fat content – Lower fat milk is more prone to curdling than higher fat varieties like whole milk.
  • Protein content – Milks with higher protein are more sensitive to curdling conditions.

To reduce the chance of curdling when making a root beer float with milk, it’s best to use cold ingredients but not extremely chilled, opt for higher fat milk, and mix the soda in slowly. Some curdling can still occur, resulting in a lumpy texture. Severely curdled milk may need to be discarded.

Milkshake Alternative

For those seeking a milkshake-like treat without ice cream, mixing root beer and milk can provide a similar flavored drink. The soda provides sweetness and bubbles, while the milk provides creaminess, resulting in a frothy, float-like beverage. However, it will not fully mimic the thick texture of a true ice cream-based milkshake.

Some tips if using root beer and milk as a milkshake alternative:

  • Use very cold ingredients to help emulsion and froth.
  • Add a scoop of ice cream if you want more thickness.
  • Blend with a blender or milk frother to create more foam.
  • Add chocolate or caramel syrup to enhance the flavor.
  • Top with whipped cream for an extra creamy texture.

While it may not be quite as indulgent, mixing chilled root beer and cold milk can create a lighter, bubbly twist on a classic milkshake.

Float Variations

Root beer and milk can also be used as the base for unique spin-off ice cream float combinations. By using milk instead of root beer alone, you create a float with a creamy balanced base. Some root beer – milk float ideas include:

Float Name Ingredients
Cookies and Cream Root beer, milk, vanilla ice cream, Oreo cookies
Mint Chip Root beer, milk, mint chip ice cream, Andes chips
Rocky Road Root beer, milk, rocky road ice cream, marshmallows

The milk helps these unique floats have a creamy balance to the root beer’s sweetness. Feel free to get creative and invent your own root beer and milk float combinations!

Potential Benefits

While not the most nutritious combination, there are some potential benefits to mixing root beer and milk together:

  • Added protein – Milk contains high quality protein, so adding it to root beer does up the protein content compared to drinking soda alone.
  • Additional nutrients – Milk provides vitamin D, calcium, vitamin A, magnesium and other nutrients not found in root beer.
  • May help hydration – The water content in milk could help offset some of the dehydrating effects of root beer’s sugar and caffeine.
  • Fun twist on classic – Mixing the two together creates a new, frothy beverage that puts a spin on an old fashioned soda float.

While not tremendously nutritious, the addition of milk to root beer does provide a bit more nutritional value, making it a fun alternative to mainstream soda.

Downsides to Mixing

There are also some potential downsides to keep in mind when mixing root beer and milk:

  • Higher in calories and sugar than plain milk.
  • Could lead to indigestion, stomach upset, or curdling.
  • Loses the full carbonation of regular root beer.
  • Alters the original flavors of both beverages.
  • Not acceptable for people with dairy/lactose intolerance.
  • May be an unusual flavor combination for some.

While delicious to some, the mixture is not for everyone. It’s best enjoyed in moderation as an occasional treat due to its high sugar content. Those with sensitivities to dairy, carbonation, or sugar may want to avoid it.

Popularity and Culture

Root beer floats have been a beloved American ice cream treat since the late 1800s. Traditionally they are made with vanilla ice cream and root beer, enjoyed through a straw, allowing the frothy soda to mix with the melting ice cream.

Using milk instead of, or in addition to, ice cream in root beer floats has become more popular in recent decades. Reasons for mixing root beer with milk include:

  • Creating a lighter, frothy float without heavy ice cream.
  • Adding creaminess and richness when lacking ice cream.
  • Making a quick soda shop-inspired treat at home.
  • Putting a new spin on the classic root beer float.
  • Using up leftover milk that is nearing expiration.

This twist on the old fashioned float has become widely used and shared online through recipes, videos, and social media. While not everyone enjoys it, plenty of people have embraced the unique taste combination of bubbly, creamy root beer mixed with milk.

How to Make a Root Beer – Milk Mixture

If you want to mix up your own batch of root beer and milk at home, follow these simple steps for best results:

  1. Start with very cold ingredients – thoroughly chill milk and root beer beforehand.
  2. Choose higher fat milk – whole or 2% work best to minimize curdling.
  3. Pour chilled milk into a tall glass – fill about 3/4 full.
  4. Slowly pour in chilled root beer – gently pour it over the back of a spoon to prevent excess fizzing.
  5. Use a straw and spoon to mix – swirling creates a frothy foam.
  6. Drink immediately or add ice cream as desired!
  7. For a large batch, mix milk and soda in a blender or mix gently with a spoon.

Feel free to tweak ratios to achieve your ideal level of sweetness and creaminess. Always use cold ingredients and mix gently to minimize curdling and keep maximum carbonation in the finished drink.

Alternatives to Root Beer

While root beer is the most common, you can make soda and milk combinations using other flavors too. Some examples include:

  • Cream soda
  • Vanilla cola
  • Ginger ale
  • Orange soda
  • Black cherry soda
  • Birch beer

Creamy, vanilla, and fruit-flavored sodas tend to complement the milk’s flavor the best. Feel free to experiment with your favorite soda varieties!

Non-Dairy Alternatives

Those avoiding dairy can also try making root beer floats with non-dairy milks such as:

  • Almond milk
  • Coconut milk
  • Oat milk
  • Soy milk
  • Rice milk

For best results, choose plain, unsweetened varieties with higher fat content to come closest to regular milk’s creamy texture. However, the taste and consistency may vary compared to using regular dairy milk.

Conclusion

While not for everyone, mixing root beer and milk creates a unique, sweet and foamy beverage. It provides a lighter twist on an ice cream float for those seeking an alternative. The soda imparts bubbly sweetness, while the milk contributes creaminess and richness when enjoying it as a treat. Just be mindful of the higher sugar content and potential for curdling when blending these two seemingly unlikely beverages together.