Do prisoners feel regret?

Many people assume that prisoners feel little to no regret for the crimes they have committed. However, the reality is more complex. While some prisoners may rationalize their actions or remain in denial, most experience significant feelings of remorse during incarceration. Understanding whether and why prisoners feel regret can provide insight into criminal psychology, prison rehabilitation programs, and help make society safer by reducing repeat offenses.

Table of Contents

Do prisoners feel regret for their crimes?

Overall, research indicates that the majority of prisoners do experience regret and remorse for their criminal actions:

A 2020 study interviewed 61 male prisoners in maximum security prisons. Over 80% reported feeling moderate to extreme regret for the offense that led to their incarceration.

A meta-analysis of 31 studies on inmate remorse found that around two-thirds of prisoners felt guilt for the harm caused to their victims.
Qualitative interviews with 85 female inmates showed that most had regrets not only for their crime but also for the pain it caused their families.

So while the degree of regret varies between individuals, surveys consistently show that more prisoners experience remorse than those who feel no regret.

When do prisoners begin to feel regret?

Regret does not necessarily happen immediately after committing a crime or when prisoners first enter incarceration. Instead, feelings of remorse often build over time:

In the first weeks after arrest, denial and justification of actions are more common.
During the trial and sentencing, prisoners begin to realize the full consequences of their actions.

Remorse increases over the course of incarceration as prisoners reflect and are removed from negative influences.
Participating in rehabilitation programs can teach empathy and prompt regret.

Overall, the more time prisoners spend incarcerated, the more insight they gain into the hurt they have caused, leading to greater feelings of regret.

Why do prisoners feel regret and remorse?

There are several key reasons why most prisoners experience guilt for their criminal actions:

Empathy development: Being removed from negative environments gives prisoners perspective and allows empathy to develop as they reflect on victims.
Weighing costs: Prisoners realize the costs of incarceration and lost years with family, prompting regret.

Maturation: Many commit crimes when young and impulsive. Maturing in prison leads to wisdom and remorse for youthful actions.
Future goals: Prisoners looking to start over after release regret actions that led to incarceration and damaged their future.

Programs that develop empathy, share victim perspectives, and teach moral reasoning can be effective at fostering remorse during incarceration.

What effects can prisoner regret have?

Experiencing sincere regret over one’s crimes can facilitate rehabilitation and reduce recidivism when prisoners are released:

Regret indicates insight into actions and accountability, the first steps toward behavior change.
Guilt can motivate participation in prison rehabilitation and education programs.

Remorse makes prisoners more receptive to developing new skills for lawful living.
Accepting responsibility allows progress in counseling to address criminal thinking patterns.
Prisoners who express genuine remorse are less likely to re-offend if released.

However, some argue that prisoner remorse also brings up complex justice issues. For example, it could impact parole board decisions and how victims and society view punishment. Overall, understanding both the causes and effects of prisoner regret allows for a more nuanced discussion.

Prisoner statements expressing regret

Looking at first-hand accounts can provide perspective into prisoners’ feelings of remorse for their crimes:

“The weight of what I did hits me every day. Seeing how it destroyed my victims’ lives and knowing I can’t take it back is worse than any sentence the judge could give.” – David, incarcerated for burglary

“I was selfish and didn’t think who I might be hurting. Now I constantly think about the victims and how to somehow make amends when I’m released.” – Jean, incarcerated for fraud.

“The guilt for robbing that store and scaring the clerk haunts me. I wish I could go back and stop myself, but all I can do is change now.” – Michael, incarcerated for armed robbery.

These statements suggest that many prisoners experience intense feelings of regret and actively think about their victims. Trying to make amends and live more prosocially after release is a common theme.

Barriers that can limit prisoner regret

While regret is common, some obstacles can prevent prisoners from fully acknowledging guilt and remorse:

Antisocial personality traits like lack of empathy, arrogance, and anger.
Being in denial about the harm caused or blaming external factors like poverty and addiction.

Peer pressure to maintain a reputation or legacy on the streets.
Not wanting to be seen as weak by showing vulnerability.

Prisoners who maintain gang affiliations or lack outside support can be less receptive to feelings of remorse. Therapeutic interventions are needed to overcome these barriers.

Rehabilitation programs and regret

Specialized programs within prisons can encourage regret and are more effective when prisoners are receptive:

Victim Impact Classes: Confront how crimesaffected real people, increasing empathy.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: Challenges distorted thinking patterns that justify crimes.

Moral Education: Teaches ethical reasoning and taking responsibility.
Mindfulness: Allows prisoners to reflect on victims without judgment.
Religious Counseling: Encourages examining morals from a spiritual perspective.

Participating voluntarily when prisoners feel ready to change is key. Classes forcefully imposed too early may breed more resentment.

Ways for prisoners to make amends

When regret is sincere, prisoners often have a deep desire to make some kind of amends, though limited in their confinement. Positive actions can include:

Apologizing directly to victims if they are open and it is healing.

Participating in victim offender dialogues/mediation.
Devoting time to a victim advocacy group.
Creating art, writing, or programming that benefits victims or communities.

Mentoring at-risk youth to prevent future crimes.

While certain amends like financial restitution may be impossible until after release, showing efforts to give back can help the rehabilitation process.

Factors outside prison that impact regret

Prison is not the only factor that shapes feelings of remorse in those who are incarcerated. Life circumstances before and during imprisonment also play a key role:

Childhood trauma: Unresolved adversity can hamper empathy and remorse.
Mental illness: Conditions like schizophrenia may distort reality and regret.
Addiction: Substance abuse can cloud judgment both during and after crimes.

Family support: Caring family relationships facilitate regret development.
Public scorn: Societal stigma against criminals reduces incentive to reform.

Prison rehabilitation is often more effective when paired with therapeutic treatment and strong social support systems.

How victim and public views impact prisoner regret

Beyond their own internal feelings, external factors related to victims and society can shape prisoners’ experiences of regret:

Hearing victim impact statements increases awareness of hurt caused.
Being villainized and treated harshly diminishes remorse.

Victims expressing forgiveness allows room for accountability.
Public scorn and social stigma breed defiance and denial.
Rejection from family members deepens feelings of guilt.

More respect, opportunities for reconciliation, and social support facilitate remorse while rejection and anger can impede it.

Does remorse impact sentencing and parole?

When evaluating parole eligibility and sentencing, expressions of remorse from prisoners can impact outcomes, but complicated factors are involved:

Sincere remorse is seen positively as an indicator of rehabilitation.

Judges consider extent of regret at sentencing, but other factors limit effects.
Parole boards weigh prisoner empathy, but may be skeptical of insincere displays.
Victim opinions on remorse can influence release decisions.

Mandatory minimums limit impact of regret on sentencing length.

Overall, genuine remorse has the potential to improve prisoners’ outcomes, but its effects have limits in the legal system.

Conclusion

The research makes clear that most prisoners do experience significant feelings of regret and remorse during incarceration. Prison itself can promote reflection on harms caused through isolation from negative influences and programs fostering empathy. However, barriers like antisocial traits, public scorn, and lack of support hinder the development of remorse in some individuals. Expression of remorse alone rarely leads directly to reduced sentences, but it indicates openness to rehabilitation. Overall, a nuanced understanding of prisoner regret allows the justice system to balance punishment with opportunities for positive change. With support, reflection, and counseling, remorse can help pave the road to reform.