As an Amazon Associate Resto earn from qualifying purchases.
Resto » Hearth Restaurant (Reviews & Ratings)

Hearth Restaurant (Reviews & Ratings)


Address: 403 E 12th St, New York, NY 10009

Restaurant Type: Fine dining restaurant

Phone: (646) 602-1300

Price: $$

Rating: 4.5


Hearth Directions

More Restaurants In New York


What Time Does Hearth Open?

Tuesday,: 5 to 9PM

Wednesday,: 2 to 9PM

Thursday,: 2 to 9PM

Friday,: 2 to 9:30PM

Saturday,: 12 to 3PM, 5 to 9:30PM

Sunday,: 12 to 3:30PM, 5 to 9PM

Monday,: 5 to 9PM

Hearth Directions

More Restaurants In New York


Hearth Reviews

Nicole Spears

Had one of the most amazing meals of my life here! 100% the best meatball of my life!! Came in a couple weeks I’ll go with my boyfriend for dinner during restaurant week. Everything was excellent! Loved the warm crispy crust on the olive oil cake and the bottle of white wine from the Canary Islands!! Our server was great. We had a really nice conversation with the manager or food runner at the end of our meal to top off a perfect evening. I will definitely return when I’m back in NYC.

Sandra Hernandez

Superb! The garlic bread is amazing. We did the tasting menu which included 8 dishes in 4 courses. We had 2 vegetable dishes, 2 pasta dishes, meatballs, cod, polenta, and dessert. Every dish was flavorful and carefully thought out for a perfect bite. The desert was also amazing, definitely recommend this restaurant for a date night or small group gathering. The restaurant actually has 2 sections inside so there seemed to be a decent amount of seating/capacity but it’s popular so I recommend a reservation. We have passed by this restaurant many times and didn’t even realize we have been missing out. Will definitely go back.

Justin Hayworth

I wanted to like it so much more…

Ambiance was lovely. The food was pretty good, but not great.

The service was bad. Really slow. Seemed like 1-2 servers MAX were working the entire restaurant (including outdoor dining) on a bustling Friday night.

Took 30 minutes to get a server to come by just to take our drink order. Food came out slowly too. Alas, they were busy and seemingly to busy for us.

5 star atmosphere.

4 star food.

2 star service.

I’d give them 4 stars if they could fix the issues we had.

Udit Anand

Really enjoyed the tasting menu at Hearth – the food was excellent even though a couple of dishes (e.g. the fava bean soup) were average. The dessert was my favorite part of the tasting menu, followed by the wild tilefish. Although a bit expensive, the food is great and definitely worth a visit!

George Betances

First time here and I was truly impressed with the explosion of flavors and amazing drinks. The striped sea bass was my pick and it was tender and so fresh. The staff were incredibly friendly with a sense of humor, I believe everything on their menu is amazing and I will come back here again

Qin Ding

gorgeous Italian restaurant cooked with health-conscious ingredients, results in mouthful of fragrant flavors. open kitchen format feels inviting. the back room (shaped like a narrow alley) provides more intimate dining experience, while the main dining room feels more like a living room with lots air and space. a shared appetizer + an entree + a drink + a shared dessert could go easily south of $100 per person for two people. worth every single dollar.


Did the tasting menu and had so much fun! Didn’t end up getting the drink tasting with it but need to try it next time!!

Nikita Carpenter

James Beard Award Winning…what else I gotta say? If you like wine, they have a beautiful selection. If your friends are carnivores, they have a 48 oz steak option. But believe me: trust the drink menu, don’t deviate. Have fun ✌

Jordan Noël Hawkes

Food is delicious. However, the portions are very small, even from the heartier selection of options. We split three dishes between the two of us and left hungry. Not a full meal for the price of a full meal. Great cocktails. Clean space but acoustics inside make it very noisy, I could hardly hear my own conversation. Based on my one experience here I don’t think I’ll go back.

My photos are pretty bad – but the food was quite the opposite. Very balanced plates. Nice fresh produce. Highly recommended

More Reviews for Hearth

More Restaurants In New York