Skip to Content

How do you tell if your hair is dry or has too much protein?


It can be tricky to figure out if your hair is dry or has too much protein. Both dryness and protein overload can leave your hair feeling brittle, straw-like, and hard to manage. However, the causes and solutions for each issue are quite different. In this article, we’ll go over the signs, causes, and treatments for dry hair versus protein overload so you can get your locks back to a healthy, balanced state. Keep reading to learn how to diagnose and treat these common hair woes.

Signs of Dry Hair

Here are some of the most common signs that your hair may be dry:

  • Brittle, dull, and frizzy texture
  • Split ends
  • Hair breaks easily
  • Lackluster shine
  • Difficult to style – won’t hold a curl or style
  • Feels rough or coarse to the touch
  • Unmanageable flyaways
  • Static and frizz, even in humid weather

When your hair is very dry, it often feels rough, frizzy, and brittle no matter what products or styling tools you use on it. The cuticles on each strand raise up when hair is dry, causing knots, tangling, and breakage. Dry hair loses its flexibility and elasticity, making it prone to damage.

Causes of Dry Hair

What leads to parched, moisture-deprived hair in the first place? Here are some of the most common culprits:

  • Harsh shampoos – Sulfate cleansers are very effective at removing oil and product buildup, but they can also strip your hair and scalp of protective natural oils.
  • Over-shampooing – Washing too frequently disrupts the hair’s natural moisture balance.
  • Hard water – Mineral deposits in hard water can leave a dull, crunchy feeling on strands.
  • Heating tools – Frequent use of blow dryers, curling irons, and straighteners dehydrate hair over time.
  • Chemical processing – Bleach, relaxers, perms, and hair dye remove lipids and proteins that keep hair supple.
  • Environmental factors – Sun, wind, and pollution damage the hair cuticle allowing moisture loss.
  • Improper diet – Not getting enough healthy fats can lead to a deficiency of fatty acids that nourish the hair.
  • Medical conditions – Thyroid disorders, anemia, and other illnesses may cause dry, shedding hair.

The most common cause of dry hair is using products and styles that continually strip away the hair’s natural moisture barrier faster than it can be replenished. However, dry air, health issues, and nutrient deficiencies can also be factors.

Signs of Protein Overload

It may seem counterintuitive, but an excess of protein can damage hair just as much as a lack of moisture. Here are signs your hair may have too much protein:

  • Stiff, straw-like texture
  • Hair feels hard and crunchy to the touch
  • Strands seem coated, rough, or tangled
  • Dull, lifeless look even when clean
  • Extremely dry, brittle, and prone to breakage
  • Frizz and lack of curl definition
  • Severe tangles and knots

Protein overload often makes the hair shaft feel rigid, coarse and brittle. Unlike dry hair, strands with too much protein typically won’t absorb moisture well, even if deep conditioning treatments are used.

Causes of Protein Overload

What can cause this protein imbalance? Here are some potential sources:

  • Using protein-heavy conditioners or treatments too often
  • Overdoing keratin treatments
  • Frequently using products with hydrolyzed proteins high on the ingredient list
  • Applying DIY treatments with things like eggs, mayo, or rice water too frequently
  • Getting permanent hair straightening or relaxing treatments too often
  • Using protein-rich products without adding enough moisture
  • Naturally high levels of protein in African American hair types

Products marketed towards frizz-control, damaged, or over-processed hair tend to be very high in proteins and polymers meant to temporarily “repair” the hair shaft. When overused, these ingredients can build up and cause brittleness. Those with already protein-dense hair are most susceptible.

Should I Avoid Protein Altogether?

Protein is an essential part of a balanced hair diet – you just don’t want to go overboard. Moderate amounts of protein can strengthen strands and reinforce the hair cuticle layer. Those with fine, limp hair or extreme damage may benefit from some added protein in their routine. Completely avoiding protein is usually not necessary – just reduce protein treatments to once a week or less. Alternatively, switch to a more moisturizing, protein-free deep conditioner for your weekly treatments if your hair seems to be in protein overload.

Treatments for Dry Hair

If your hair is chronically dry and brittle, adjust your routine to add more hydrating, moisturizing products. Here are some tips for treating parched strands:

  • Cut back on shampooing and use a gentle, sulfate-free cleanser
  • Switch to a moisturizing conditioner and leave-in treatment
  • Apply masks with oils, shea butter, aloe vera or honey once a week
  • Rinse hair with cool water to seal the cuticle
  • Let hair air dry when possible instead of heat styling
  • Sleep on a satin pillowcase to avoid moisture loss and friction
  • Use hydrating styling products like leave-ins, creams and oils
  • Get regular trims to snip split ends before they travel up the length of hair

Focus on restoring moisture balance to your hair. Deep condition once a week and avoid thermal styling to let your hair recover its supple, hydrated feel.

Treatments for Protein Overload

If you suspect protein overload, do a clarifying wash to remove buildup, then make these adjustments:

  • Switch to a moisturizing shampoo and conditioner free of proteins
  • Cut back on stylers like mousse, gel, or pomade that can contain protein
  • Do a weekly deep conditioning treatment focused only on hydration – no protein!
  • Rinse out all conditioner thoroughly and avoid “coating” products
  • Brush hair gently when wet and use a wide-tooth comb
  • Avoid heat styling until hair regains elasticity and softness

Focus on moisture-restoring ingredients like shea butter, coconut oil, olive oil, aloe vera, and panthenol (vitamin B5). Avoid ANY products containing hydrolyzed proteins, collagen, keratin, or silk amino acids until hair rebalances.

The Strand Test

One way to check if your hair is overloaded on protein or just dry is to do a simple strand test:

  1. Wash a few strands of hair and let them air dry completely.
  2. Hold the dry strands between your fingers and try to stretch them.
  3. If the hair stretches easily without breaking, it is just dry and needs added moisture.
  4. If the strand feels stiff and snaps apart easily without stretching, your hair is likely overloaded on protein.

Healthy hair should have some elasticity – overly hard, brittle strands are a sign to cut back on protein. This quick test can help diagnose whether moisture or protein is needed.

Should I Use a Clarifying Shampoo?

A clarifying shampoo is a great option if your hair is feeling coated, stiff, or greasy from too much product buildup. These shampoos contain detergents to deep clean the hair and remove mineral deposits, styling products, oils, and anything else that could be weighing your hair down.

Look for clarifying shampoos with these ingredients:

  • Citric acid
  • Sodium chloride
  • Magnesium sulfate
  • EDTA
  • Sodium lauryl sulfate
  • Sodium lauroyl sarcosinate

Use a clarifying wash once a week or as needed if hair seems limp, greasy, or is suffering from hard water residue. But avoid over-clarifying, as this can lead to dryness.

Moisture-Protein Balance

Both moisture and protein are essential for healthy hair – you need to strike the right balance. Think of protein products as strength trainers that reinforce the hair shaft, while moisture is the conditioning “recovery” phase. Alternate between the two and listen to what your hair needs.

Tips for Balanced Hair:

  • Use a protein treatment 1x per week maximum
  • Deep condition with moisture-rich masks 1-2x per week
  • Switch up your shampoo and conditioner systems
  • Clarify only when needed to avoid drying hair out
  • Avoid over-manipulating or heat styling fragile hair
  • Trim regularly to prevent split ends from worsening
  • Get trims or dustings every 6-8 weeks

The key is not overdoing either protein or moisture. Pay attention to what your hair responds best to and adjust your products accordingly. With some trial and error, you’ll find the right combination.

Ingredients to Watch For

Learn to read ingredient lists to pick products tailored to your hair’s needs.

Moisturizing Ingredients:

  • Glycerin
  • Panthenol
  • Aloe vera
  • Honey
  • Shea butter
  • Jojoba oil
  • Argan oil
  • Avocado oil
  • Coconut oil
  • Olive oil
  • Cetearyl alcohol
  • Dimethicone
  • Hyaluronic acid

Protein-Based Ingredients:

  • Hydrolyzed wheat protein
  • Hydrolyzed soy protein
  • Hydrolyzed collagen
  • Keratin
  • Amino acids
  • Silk protein
  • Rice protein

Learn to identify protein-free versus protein-rich products so you can create a regimen tailored to your hair’s needs. Switch up moisturizing and strengthening treatments as needed.

Conclusion

Keeping your hair balanced with the right ratio of protein to moisture is key to maintaining soft, supple, healthy hair. Learn to recognize the signs of dryness versus protein overload and adjust your regimen accordingly. With some trial and error, you’ll be able to create a customized routine to achieve your best hair yet. The most important tip is to pay attention to what your hair is telling you and provide it with what it needs – whether that’s more hydration or less protein. Listen to your hair and tweak your products until you’ve found the perfect moisture-protein balance.