Skip to Content

How do you thaw a frozen buttermilk pie?

Buttermilk pie is a delicious southern dessert made with buttermilk, eggs, sugar, flour, butter, and vanilla. It has a smooth, creamy custard-like texture and a tangy buttermilk flavor. Buttermilk pie is simple to make but does require some advance planning since the pie needs to be chilled before serving. Leftover buttermilk pie can be frozen for longer term storage, but thawing it properly is important to maintain the texture.

Can you freeze buttermilk pie?

Yes, you can absolutely freeze leftover buttermilk pie. Freezing is a great way to store buttermilk pie and extend its shelf life for up to 2-3 months. To freeze buttermilk pie, first make sure the pie is completely cooled after baking. Then wrap the whole pie tightly in a layer of plastic wrap followed by a layer of aluminum foil. The plastic wrap helps prevent freezer burn while the foil provides an extra moisture barrier. Label the foil with the contents and freeze date before placing in the freezer. Freeze the pie for up to 2-3 months until ready to thaw and serve.

How long does it take to thaw a frozen buttermilk pie?

It takes about 24 hours to safely thaw a frozen buttermilk pie in the refrigerator. Thawing slowly in the fridge helps maintain the texture and prevent any curdling or weeping of the filling. Do not try to rush thaw buttermilk pie on the counter or in warm water, as this can cause safety issues and affect the quality. Allow the following thaw times:

Thaw Method Time
Refrigerator 24 hours
Room temperature Not recommended
Microwave Not recommended

Once thawed in the fridge for 24 hours, the buttermilk pie is ready to serve! The texture should be just like fresh baked.

How to thaw frozen buttermilk pie

Follow these simple steps for thawing frozen buttermilk pie properly:

  1. Remove the pie from the freezer and unwrap the plastic wrap and foil.
  2. Place the pie in the refrigerator on a plate or pie dish. Allow it to thaw for 24 full hours until completely defrosted.
  3. Check the pie halfway through thawing. If any condensation has accumulated on the surface, dab it away with a paper towel.
  4. Once thawed, the pie is ready to serve! Slice and enjoy the buttermilk pie chilled.
  5. Do not try to accelerate thawing by leaving the pie at room temperature or microwaving it, as this alters the texture.
  6. If the pie will not be served shortly after thawing, leave it refrigerated until ready to serve. Buttermilk pie can be stored refrigerated for 3-4 days.

Can you refreeze thawed buttermilk pie?

It is not recommended to refreeze buttermilk pie after it has been completely thawed. Refreezing can lead to weeping, grainy texture, and loss of flavor. The best approach is to thaw only what you plan to consume within 3-4 days. Any remaining thawed pie should be covered and stored in the refrigerator. Do not attempt to freeze the pie again after thawing.

Signs of improper thawing of buttermilk pie

If a buttermilk pie did not thaw properly, you may notice some of these issues with the texture and appearance:

  • Weeping liquid or moisture on the surface
  • Custard appears curdled or separated
  • Pie filling is grainy or crystallized
  • Crust is soggy or soft
  • Loss of flavor
  • Pie slices don’t hold shape when served

These changes occur when the buttermilk pie is thawed too quickly or at too high of a temperature. Stick to the gradual thawing guidelines to maintain the best pie quality.

Storing thawed buttermilk pie

Once thawed, store any uneaten buttermilk pie in the refrigerator, covered, for 3-4 days maximum. Make sure to thaw only what you will consume shortly to prevent waste. Do not leave the pie sitting out at room temperature once thawed. For longer term storage, wrap leftover pie to freeze again following the same technique used initially. The thawed pie can be frozen for an additional 1-2 months if properly wrapped.

Serving thawed buttermilk pie

Here are some tips for serving thawed buttermilk pie at its best:

  • Refrigerate pie until ready to serve, do not leave out at room temperature
  • Let the pie sit at room temperature for 15 minutes prior to serving if you prefer a less chilled texture
  • Slice the pie with a thin, sharp knife in one smooth motion for clean slices
  • Use a pie server to transfer slices neatly to individual plates
  • Garnish slices with fresh whipped cream or vanilla ice cream if desired
  • Cover and refrigerate any leftover pie within 2 hours of serving

Following proper thawing, storing, and serving guidelines will result in a buttermilk pie with the same smooth, creamy texture and tangy flavor as fresh baked. Enjoy this classic Southern dessert any time of year with frozen leftovers on hand.

Tips for freezing buttermilk pie

Follow these tips for the best results freezing buttermilk pie:

  • Let the pie cool completely before freezing
  • Use quality freezer wrap – plastic wrap pressed directly against the pie surface and a layer of foil over top
  • Wrap the pie tightly with no air pockets
  • Label the foil wrap with contents and freeze date
  • Freeze for up to 2-3 months for best quality
  • Thaw in the refrigerator for 24 hours before serving
  • Do not refreeze after thawing

Common questions about thawing buttermilk pie

Can you put frozen buttermilk pie straight into the oven?

No, do not put frozen buttermilk pie straight into the oven. It must be fully thawed in the refrigerator first before baking or serving. The custard filling requires gradual thawing for the best outcome.

Can you microwave frozen buttermilk pie to thaw?

Microwaving is not recommended for thawing frozen buttermilk pie. The microwave thaws unevenly and can create hot spots that curdle the custard. Thaw the pie gradually in the refrigerator only.

What temperature should thawed buttermilk pie be served?

Thawed buttermilk pie is best served chilled. Let it sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes before serving if you prefer a slightly less chilled texture. But do not allow the pie to sit at room temperature for longer than 2 hours.

How can you tell when frozen buttermilk pie is thawed?

Check for signs of thawing like softened crust and creamy, spreadable filling. The pie should feel refrigerated cold when thawed, not frozen or icy. Thaw times can vary based on pie size. Most pies need 24 hours in the fridge.

Can frozen buttermilk pie be thawed at room temperature?

No, room temperature thawing is unsafe and will negatively impact the pie’s texture. The custard filling can curdle, separate, or develop a grainy texture if thawed too quickly. Refrigerator thawing is best.


With proper freezing and thawing techniques, leftover buttermilk pie will maintain its delicious flavor and smooth, creamy texture for months after baking. Allow 24 hours to thaw the pie gradually in the refrigerator before slicing and serving the pie chilled. Do not refreeze after thawing or rush the thawing process. Follow these simple guidelines for enjoying your buttermilk pie at its very best, even when working with frozen leftovers.