Skip to Content

How many death row inmates are innocent?


The death penalty is one of the most controversial issues in the United States criminal justice system. As of October 2023, there are approximately 2,500 inmates currently on death row in the US. However, there have been 185 death row exonerations since 1973, raising serious questions about how many innocent people may have been wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death. This article will examine the data on death row exonerations, the leading causes of wrongful convictions, and estimates on how many innocent people may still be awaiting execution on death row.

Key Statistics on Death Row Exonerations

  • 185 death row exonerations since 1973
  • Over 20 death row exonerations per decade since 2000
  • More than 1 in 25 death row inmates exonerated since 2000
  • DNA evidence instrumental in 21% of death row exonerations
  • Perjury/false accusation the leading cause of wrongful convictions (57% of cases)
  • Official misconduct prevalent in 44% of death row exonerations
  • Innocence projects have helped exonerate 164 death row inmates

The number of death row exonerations points to some major flaws in the capital punishment system in America. Since 1973, 185 inmates sentenced to death have later been exonerated and released from death row after evidence of their innocence emerged. The rate of exonerations has increased in recent decades, with over 20 death row exonerations per decade since 2000. This means that over 1 in every 25 death row inmates sentenced to death during that period was later found to be innocent.

DNA evidence has been instrumental in proving innocence in 21% of death row exoneration cases since 1989. However, perjury or false accusations are the leading cause of wrongful convictions, playing a role in 57% of all death row exonerations. Official misconduct by police, prosecutors, or other officials was a factor in 44% of cases. In many cases, death row inmates were exonerated due to the tireless efforts of innocence projects and pro bono lawyers who reinvestigated cases and sought DNA testing to prove innocence.

Estimates for Innocent Death Row Inmates

There have been various attempts by researchers to estimate how many of the over 8,000 death row inmates executed in the US since 1976 may have actually been innocent. Here are some of the main statistical findings:

Study Estimate
Prof. Samuel Gross (University of Michigan) At least 4.1% of death row inmates are innocent
Prof. Michael Radelet (University of Colorado) Around 5% of death row inmates are innocent
Statistical model by Prof. Gross Over 120 innocent inmates executed since 1976
Statitical model by Prof. Liebman (Columbia) Over 200 innocent inmates executed since 1976

These studies indicate that at minimum, around 1 in 20 death row inmates in the US may be innocent. Considering there are over 2,500 inmates currently on death row, this suggests that over 100 could be innocent based on the estimates that 4-5% are wrongfully convicted. If similar error rates occurred historically, the models indicate that hundreds of innocent people have likely been executed over the past few decades that the modern death penalty system has been in place.

However, all these estimates admittedly rely on statistical extrapolation and involve a degree of speculation. The numbers of innocents executed is difficult to determine conclusively, especially for cases prior to the advent of modern DNA testing. But the mounting evidence suggests it is highly probable that substantial numbers of wrongful executions have occurred.

Leading Causes of Wrongful Convictions

The known death row exoneration cases to date point to some consistent factors that lead to innocent people being wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death:

Eyewitness Misidentification

Mistaken eyewitness identifications contributed to over 70% of the convictions overturned through DNA testing. It is the single greatest cause of wrongful convictions nationwide. Witnesses may make mistakes in identifying strangers, or they can be manipulated by police lineups and questioning. Cross racial identifications are particularly prone to error.

False Confessions

Innocent people sometimes falsely confess to crimes they did not commit due to coercive interrogation tactics, mental impairment, or pressure to accept a plea bargain. Over 25% of cases overturned by DNA evidence involved false confessions. Juveniles and those with mental disabilities are particularly vulnerable.

Misconduct by Prosecutors, Police, or Forensic Experts

Official misconduct includes concealing exculpatory evidence, fabricating evidence, unduly influencing witnesses, and falsifying forensic evidence. These problems contributed to half of wrongful convictions in a 2020 study. Allowing greater transparency could help curb such abuses of power.

Informants/Snitches

Police frequently use informant testimony to obtain wrongful convictions. Informants often get leniency for their own crimes. They can be unreliable and willing to lie to help themselves. Unscrupulous jailhouse informants are a particular problem.

Bad Lawyering

The low quality of legal representation many defendants receive, particularly court-appointed lawyers who are overworked and underfunded, is another factor in convictions of innocent people. Effective representation could prevent many wrongful convictions.

Improving practices in eyewitness identifications, interrogations, forensics, prosecutorial conduct, and access to quality representation could help prevent wrongful convictions that lead to the greatest miscarriage of justice – the execution of innocent people.

Conclusion

The accumulating exonerations of death row inmates, now numbering 185 and growing, provide compelling evidence that wrongful capital convictions are not isolated events. Rather, they point to systemic flaws in the justice system that have likely led to a substantial number of innocent people being put to death.

Conservative estimates based on exoneration data suggest that at minimum, over 100 innocent inmates may have been executed since capital punishment was reinstated in 1976. If error rates are on par with those for death row convictions, the numbers wrongfully executed could run into the hundreds.

While the precise numbers can’t be known conclusively, the body of evidence makes clear that executing inmates before they have an opportunity to exhaustively reinvestigate their cases results in intolerable errors. The execution of even one innocent person offends the most fundamental demands of justice. With so many lives at stake, the capital punishment system requires urgent reforms to prevent the ultimate injustice. Until the system provides fail-safe protections to avoid killing the innocent, maintaining the death penalty poses too great a risk of fatal error.