Skip to Content

Is cobbler crust the same as pie crust?

Cobbler and pie are two classic American desserts that share some similarities but also have distinct differences. Both cobbler and pie have a filling that is topped with some type of dough or batter before baking. However, the crusts and overall construction of cobbler and pie are not the same.

The crust

The biggest difference between cobbler and pie is the crust. Pie has a bottom and side crust made from pastry dough. Cobbler has a top crust only made from biscuit dough or batter.

Pie crust is made from flour, fat, and a small amount of liquid bound together into a dough. It can be filled before baking, or the bottom crust can be pre-baked before filling. Pie dough creates a robust crust that can hold up to wet fillings. It has a flakey texture from pockets of fat incorporated into the dough.

Classic pie crust uses shortening or lard for the fat component. Butter can also be used to create a flakier crust. Vinegar or lemon juice are usually used as the liquid component. Pie dough can also be made using oil instead of solid fats to create a more tender, cookie-like crust.

Cobbler crust is more similar to a biscuit dough. It is made from flour, baking powder, salt, milk or buttermilk, and butter or shortening. Sometimes eggs and sugar are also added. The cobbler batter may also include flavorings like cinnamon, nutmeg, or vanilla.

Cobbler crust has a much more tender, cake-like texture than the flakey pie crust. Since the cobbler crust bakes on top of the filling, it does not need to be sturdy enough to hold a shape or contain a wet filling.

Construction

In addition to the crust, pies and cobblers differ in how they are assembled.

Pies are constructed in a plate or pan and then baked:

  • The bottom pie crust is pressed into a pie plate or pan.
  • The filling is added on top of the bottom crust.
  • A top pie crust is placed over the filling and sealed to the bottom crust.
  • Vents or shapes are cut into the top crust.
  • The whole pie is baked until the crust and filling are cooked through.

Cobblers are assembled right in the baking dish:

  • The baking dish is greased, usually with butter.
  • The fruit filling is placed in the baking dish.
  • The biscuit dough or batter is spooned or poured over the top of the fruit.
  • The cobbler is baked until the crust and filling are cooked through.

The major difference is that the filling and crust layers are flipped between pie and cobbler. Pie crust encases the filling, while cobbler topping rests on top of the filling.

Filling

The fillings used in pie and cobbler also tend to differ.

Typical cobbler fillings:

  • Fruits – peaches, berries, apples, etc.
  • Fruit jam or preserves
  • Canned pie filling

Typical pie fillings:

  • Cooked fruit – apples, cherries, blueberries
  • Custards – pumpkin, pecan, chocolate cream
  • Puddings
  • Meats – chicken, turkey, beef
  • Vegetables – sweet potato, spinach, onion

Cobblers most commonly use raw fruits as filling, especially summer berries, stone fruits, and apples. Pies can be filled with fruit fillings, but also cooked fillings like custard and meat. Cobblers rarely use non-fruit fillings.

Purpose

Cobblers and pies fill slightly different dessert niches.

Pies are more versatile desserts. They can make a formal dessert presentation for holidays and special occasions. But they also work as humble everyday desserts. Pies can be eaten out of hand or plated and served with ice cream or whipped cream.

Cobblers are most often served warm out of the oven in a bowl. They are cozy, comforting desserts. Cobblers are typically made during peak fruit harvest times when fruit is abundant.

Flavor

Pie and cobbler flavors are largely determined by the filling. However, the crust also impacts flavor.

Pie crust is usually fairly neutral tasting, lending just a hint of richness from the fat and touch of complexity from the acids. This allows the filling flavor to take center stage.

Cobbler biscuit crust has more flavor of its own from the butter, milk, eggs, and any flavorings like cinnamon and vanilla. It typically plays a larger role in the overall flavor profile of the dessert.

Here are some classic cobbler and pie flavor pairings:

Cobbler Pie
Peach cobbler Peach pie
Blueberry cobbler Blueberry pie
Apple cobbler Apple pie
Strawberry cobbler Strawberry rhubarb pie
Cherry cobbler Cherry pie
Mixed berry cobbler Mixed berry pie

Variations

While classic cobbler and pie recipes differ, there are some variations that blend elements of the two.

Some pies replace part or all of the bottom crust with a crumbly biscuit dough. These “cookie crust pies” are easier to make than a flaky pie dough crust. They also absorb some liquid from juicy fillings.

There are also “double crust cobblers” that place a pie crust dough on the bottom and the cobbler biscuit layer on top. This combines the tenderness of a cobbler with the sturdiness of a pie crust.

Crisps and crumbles are quite similar to cobblers. The only difference is that they use a streusel or crumble type topping instead of a biscuit dough layer.

Making cobbler crust vs pie crust

If you’re new to baking, cobbler crust is a much more approachable place to start over pie crust. Pie dough requires more skill to achieve a light, flaky texture.

Cobbler biscuit dough comes together quickly by cutting the butter into the flour mixture and then stirring in liquid ingredients. Pie dough requires carefully rolling solid fat into the flour to coat it before adding liquid.

Cobbler dough can just be dropped, poured, or tossed over the fruit before baking. Pie dough needs to be carefully rolled out and shaped into the pan. Cobbler assembly is much more forgiving.

Make this easy peach cobbler for your first cobbler crust attempt:

Ingredients

  • 6 cups sliced peaches
  • 1 Tbsp lemon juice
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1 cup flour
  • 2 tsp baking powder
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • 1/4 cup butter, melted
  • 1/2 cup milk

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 375°F. Grease an 8-inch baking dish.
  2. Place peach slices in prepared baking dish. Drizzle with lemon juice and 1/4 cup sugar. Toss to coat.
  3. In a bowl, mix flour, baking powder, salt, and 1/2 cup sugar.
  4. Add melted butter and milk. Stir just until combined into a thick batter.
  5. Drop large spoonfuls of batter over the peaches. Spread evenly to cover the fruit.
  6. Bake for 30-35 minutes until topping is cooked through and golden. Serve warm.

Once you’ve mastered a simple cobbler, move on to a basic double crust pie if you want more of a challenge. Use refrigerated store-bought dough or try making your own. The sky’s the limit for creative pie fillings too!

Conclusion

While cobbler and pie are two of America’s classic baked fruit desserts, they are constructed quite differently. Pie has a bottom and top crust encasing a filling, while cobblers put the fruit filling in the dish first and then top it with biscuit dough. The crusts are also unique – flaky pie dough versus soft biscuit cobbler topping. Both delicious in their own right, cobblers and pies each shine in different situations. Cobblers for a down home dessert to share, and pies for holidays and occasions. As long as you have fruit and dough, you’re well on your way to a sweet treat.