Skip to Content

Is it illegal to rip a dollar bill?

Ripping up money, especially dollar bills, is something many people have likely done at some point. Perhaps it was done absentmindedly, or perhaps it was done to make a statement. But is intentionally ripping up dollar bills actually illegal? Let’s take a closer look at what the law says.

The Short Answer

Technically, yes – it is illegal to intentionally rip up US currency. Under Title 18, Section 333 of the United States Code, defacing, mutilating, or otherwise damaging US currency with the intent to render it “unfit to be reissued” can be fined or imprisoned for up to 6 months.

What the Law Says

The specific law that prohibits ripping up dollar bills is Title 18, Section 333 of the US Code. This law states:

“Whoever mutilates, cuts, defaces, disfigures, or perforates, or unites or cements together, or does any other thing to any bank bill, draft, note, or other evidence of debt issued by any national banking association, or Federal Reserve bank, or the Federal Reserve System, with intent to render such bank bill, draft, note, or other evidence of debt unfit to be reissued, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than six months, or both.”

So in simple terms, intentionally damaging or defacing US currency in a way that renders it unsuitable for circulation is against federal law and punishable by fine or imprisonment.

Key Elements of the Law

There are a few key elements worth highlighting in this law:

  • It applies to all US currency, including bills, notes, drafts, etc. So ripping up a dollar bill would fall under this law.
  • The defacing or damage has to be done with the intent to render the currency unfit for circulation. Accidental damage is not illegal.
  • The penalty is a fine, up to 6 months in prison, or both. So ripping money is not a trivial offense.

So if someone intentionally rips up a dollar bill to make a point or prevent further circulation, that would violate Section 333 and could result in prosecution.

Exceptions and Defenses

There are some potential exceptions and defenses to consider as well:

Collectibles

If the damaged currency is clearly meant to be kept as a collectible or novelty item, and not used as circulation currency, it may not violate the law. But this depends on demonstrating intent.

Accidental Damage

If the damage to the currency was clearly accidental and incidental, with no intent to render it unfit for circulation, this may provide a defense against prosecution.

Minimal Damage

Slight, minimal damage that does not clearly impact the fitness of a bill for circulation may not rise to the level of criminality. But there is no clear threshold here.

First Amendment Rights

Critics have argued that prohibiting the defacement of currency may violate free speech rights. However, courts have largely upheld laws against currency defacement as constitutional.

So while there are some limited exceptions, in general purposefully ripping up dollar bills or currency violates federal law and could result in criminal charges.

Enforcement Actions

Prosecutions related solely to minor damage of small amounts of currency are rare. However, there are some examples of enforcement actions:

  • In 2019, a Minnesota man was charged for ripping up dollar bills as tips.
  • In 2018, an Arkansas man was arrested for tearing up two $1 bills at a store.
  • There have been some arrests of people stamping currency with political messages.

So while not heavily prosecuted, there is precedent for arrests related to intentional currency damage and defacement.

Reasons for the Law

There are some public policy reasons behind prohibiting currency defacement and mutilation:

  • Preventing damage helps currency maintain a uniform appearance.
  • It prevents people from stamping or writing inappropriate or offensive things on bills.
  • It helps the currency system run efficiently by keeping all bills equally valid and identifiable.

So the intent is to maintain integrity and efficiency of the US currency system as a whole.

The Federal Reserve’s Role

Under federal regulations, the US Federal Reserve handles the reimbursement and replacement of damaged and mutilated US currency. Some key points on their policies:

  • They will redeem damaged bills as long as more than 50% of the original note is present.
  • There are no penalties or questions asked for redeeming damaged bills.
  • However, intentionally defaced bills may be forfeited rather than redeemed.

So even if a dollar bill is accidentally torn or damaged, as long as you have more than half of it, you can send it to the Federal Reserve and get it replaced at full face value.

State Laws

In addition to federal law, some states also have laws prohibiting currency defacement or mutilation. These may impose additional penalties or restrictions beyond the federal statute.

California

California Penal Code Section 648 makes it illegal to intentionally damage, mutilate, or scrawl on bank bills or notes. The punishment can be county jail time up to one year or a fine up to $1000. Notably, repeated offenses can be charged as felonies.

Illinois

In Illinois, Criminal Code Section 17-15 prohibits mutilating or defacing any bank bill or coin. Violations are considered petty offenses punishable by fines up to $1500 and up to a year in jail.

New York

Under New York state law, defacing or rendering any bank bill or coin unfit for circulation is considered criminal tampering and can be punished as a Class B misdemeanor offense.

So state laws may provide additional penalties beyond federal currency mutilation laws.

Practical Considerations

In practical terms, here are a few things to keep in mind when it comes to damaging dollar bills:

  • Be careful ripping up old bills or notes – if you have over 50% of the bill, it can likely be redeemed.
  • Avoid any intentional defacement of bills with stamps or writing.
  • Minimal damage like small tears or worn edges generally will not risk prosecution.
  • There is little tolerance for intentionally damaging currency as political protest.
  • Accidentally damaged bills can be replaced – but intentionally defaced ones forfeited.

While charging someone for a small tear seems extreme, intentionally rendering a bill unusable crosses the line into illegal behavior in most cases.

Ethical Considerations

There are some ethical implications around defacing or destroying currency that are worth contemplating:

  • Is it ethical to destroy money when some have so little?
  • Should we avoid wasting resources or symbolically damaging assets?
  • Does defacement of government property undermine institutions?
  • Is there a freedom of speech argument for political currency modification?

There are good faith arguments on both sides of these ethical debates. Some view any destruction of money as wasteful, while others see it as protected free speech. There are also debates around if and when civil disobedience against government policies may be justified. These are complex issues deserving of thoughtful analysis.

The Bottom Line

Intentional ripping, tearing or defacing of US currency is prohibited under federal law. Regulations, ethics and state laws also strongly discourage rendering bills unusable. But practical considerations like minimal damage, accidental harm or collectible status provide some legal flexibility. So while not the gravest offense, purposefully ripping up dollar bills crosses the line into technically illegal behavior in most cases.

Conclusion

Ripping up dollar bills, while sometimes done for emphasis or spontaneity, violates a federal law intended to protect the integrity of US currency. Anyone who intentionally defaces or damages currency risks not just replacement or confiscation of their bills, but potentially fines or imprisonment if prosecuted. However, there are important exceptions like accidental harm, minimal damage, and collectible status that provide some legal leeway. Ethics and state laws also come into play around currency defacement. So while not heavily prosecuted, deliberately damaging or writing on paper money remains officially illegal in America.