Skip to Content

Is it OK to call in sick?


Calling in sick to work when you are not actually ill is an ethical dilemma that many employees face at some point in their careers. On one hand, taking a day off when you are not truly sick can feel dishonest and irresponsible. On the other hand, there are times when calling in sick, even if you are not physically ill, can be justified and even mentally healthy. This article will examine the pros, cons, ethics, and best practices around calling in sick when you need a day off.

When is it acceptable to call in sick?

There are some cases when calling in sick to work is understandable and acceptable:

You have an illness that is not physically debilitating

Having a bad cold, sinus infection, migraine, or stomach bug may not completely prevent you from working, but can make getting through the day miserable. It can be reasonable to call in sick with these types of ailments, even if you could technically drag yourself into work. Listen to what your body needs.

You need to take care of someone who is sick

Caring for a child, spouse or elderly parent who is ill is a valid reason to call in sick. You are still playing a caretaking role that necessitates missing work.

You have a medical appointment

Rather than taking a full vacation day for a doctor or dentist appointment, it can be appropriate to take a sick day. This allows you to save vacation days for actual leisure time.

Mental health day

Sometimes you may really need a break for your mental wellbeing, whether due to stress, anxiety, depression, grief, or just general burnout. Using sick time for mental health can be beneficial.

Bereavement

The death of a loved one is a tragic event that understandably requires time off work. While companies often offer bereavement leave policies, if that is not an option, calling in sick for bereavement is reasonable.

When is it unacceptable to call in sick?

There are also instances when calling in sick when you are not ill is unwise and unethical:

You are not sick at all

Calling in sick when you simply do not feel like going to work or you want to do something else is dishonest. Make sure you can genuinely justify to yourself why you need the day off.

You want to extend your weekend or vacation

Adding an extra day onto a vacation or long weekend by calling in sick is usually obvious and frowned upon. Honor the allotted time you requested off.

Every Monday or Friday

A pattern of calling in sick on Mondays or Fridays makes it look like you are just trying to extend your weekend. Even if you are really sick, frequent absences before/after weekends raise suspicions.

Hangovers

Calling in sick due to a hangover looks unprofessional and signals poor judgment. Drink responsibly on work nights.

Fake illness

Making up symptoms like a cough or stomachache to sound sick is unethical. Be honest if you are taking a mental health day.

What are the risks of calling in sick when you are not?

While it can be convenient to call in sick when you need a personal day, it does come with some risks, including:

  • Using up sick time – You may need those days later if you actually get very ill.
  • Letting colleagues down – Coworkers may have to cover for you or pick up your slack when you’re gone.
  • Setting a bad example – If you are in a leadership role, this could promote absenteeism culture.
  • Raising suspicion – Pattern may hint that you are looking for jobs, disengaged or dishonest.
  • Attendance policy violation – Frequent dubious absences could result in disciplinary action.
  • Reputation damage – Word spreading that you “fake” sick days could hurt trust.
  • Progress delays – Projects and tasks that depend on you may be stalled.

Think carefully before calling in sick when you aren’t truly ill, as it can impact coworkers, your career progression, and company success.

How often is too often to call in sick?

How many sick days are too many can depend on your company policy and situation:

  • More than 5 sick days per year may raise concerns if there is no medical justification.
  • 1-2 sick days per month is likely excessive barring chronic illness.
  • 3 sick days in a row should have a doctor’s note.
  • Always using up 100% of allotted sick time looks suspicious.
  • A pattern of Mondays and/or Fridays is problematic.
  • Any days adjacent to vacations or holidays could draw scrutiny.

As a rule of thumb, if your sick days are garnering attention or Expressing concern from a manager, HR or colleagues, it is time to reevaluate how often and when you call in.

How can you ethically call in sick when you are not?

If you do need a day off for wellbeing but are not actually sick, there are some best practices to maintain integrity:

  • Check your employee handbook for mental health or personal leave policies. Follow appropriate procedures.
  • Request the time off in advance rather than morning-of calling in sick.
  • Be honest if asked directly why you need the day. Say it is for mental health or a personal matter.
  • If sick time does not require a doctor’s note, you do not need to fabricate medical reasons.
  • Offer to help make up the work or be available by phone/email if urgent needs arise.
  • Thank coworkers who step in for you and express appreciation.

Following policies, communicating transparently where possible, and maintaining positive relationships despite your absence can help preserve trust and mutual respect.

What are some alternatives to calling in sick?

If calling in sick when you are not ill does not feel right to you, some other options to consider are:

Taking a vacation day

Many companies offer paid vacation days that can be used for mental breaks.

Working from home

If your work allows, telecommuting for a day can provide a change of environment.

Taking unpaid leave

You may be able to take an unpaid personal day if allowed by your company policy.

Using flextime

Making up the missed hours by working flexibly on other days can avoid vacation/sick day use.

Talking to your manager

Having an open discussion about needing rejuvenation can reveal solutions and understanding.

Planning a vacation

Looking ahead to an upcoming vacation can help you push through to the time off.

Taking intermittent FMLA

If eligible, FMLA can protect absences for mental health needs.

What to do if your boss suspects you of taking fake sick days?

If a manager has approached you about dubious sick day patterns, possible responses include:

– Apologize genuinely for any suspicions caused.

– Explain truthfully why you needed the days if mental health related.

– Offer to provide medical documentation if the absences were health justified.

– Propose making up any missed work or meetings.

– Assure them it will not become a pattern.

– Request using personal days in the future instead of sick leave.

– Seek solutions like flextime or remote work alternatives.

– Thank them for bringing the concern to your attention directly.

– Express your commitment to the job and not letting the team down.

Handling the conversation with maturity, empathy and accountability can go a long way in smoothing things over and preventing future questions.

Conclusion

Calling in sick when you are not truly ill can be problematic if done unethically or excessively. However, the occasional mental health day may be justified and actually improve productivity and morale in the long run. Being conscious of your motivations, careful about frequency, transparent where possible, and considerate of colleagues can allow you to take needed personal time while maintaining positive working relationships. If abuse is suspected, earnestly addressing concerns and proving your commitment is wise. With open communication and thoughtful moderation, time off for wellness can be mutually beneficial for both employees and employers.