Skip to Content

Is pumping more tiring than breastfeeding?

For many new mothers, deciding between pumping breast milk or breastfeeding directly can be a difficult choice. Both options have their own sets of pros and cons when it comes to convenience, time commitment, and comfort. Ultimately, whether pumping or nursing is more tiring depends on the individual mother and baby.

The Pros and Cons of Pumping

Pumping breast milk allows mothers more flexibility and freedom. Here are some of the main pros and cons of pumping:

Pros:

  • Allows someone else to feed the baby expressed milk
  • Provides milk for times when direct nursing isn’t possible
  • Allows mother to leave the house for periods of time
  • Allows mother to measure and track milk intake
  • Milk can be stored for later use

Cons:

  • Time spent setting up and pumping
  • Need to pump as often as baby feeds
  • Cleaning pump parts after each use
  • Potential discomfort or difficulties getting let-down reflex
  • Possibility of decreased milk supply if not pumped often enough
  • Bottles need washing after each use

The time commitment of pumping is one of the biggest cons compared to direct nursing. To maintain milk supply, the general rule is to pump each time baby feeds, or at least 8-12 times in 24 hours. This means taking the time to set up the pump, pump for 15-30 minutes per session, store the milk, and clean all parts after each use. In contrast, direct nursing can be done much more quickly and easily.

The Pros and Cons of Breastfeeding

Here are some of the main pros and cons of breastfeeding directly:

Pros:

  • Convenience of feeding on demand
  • Bonding time with baby
  • Comfort of skin-to-skin contact
  • No pump parts to wash
  • Milk supply regulates to baby’s needs

Cons:

  • Mother must be present for all feedings
  • Feedings can be frequent, especially in the first few months
  • Potential discomfort or difficulties with latch
  • Leaking milk between feedings
  • Restriction on mother’s activities and diet

The main con of breastfeeding is that the mother must be present for all feedings. Even if the baby feeds efficiently, the frequent feeding schedule in the early months can feel tiring. However, direct nursing allows feeding on demand without the extra steps of pumping and bottle washing.

Comparing Time Commitment

To get a better sense of the time commitment required, let’s compare what a typical daily pumping schedule looks like versus breastfeeding.

For pumping, the schedule would look something like this:

Time Pumping Task Duration
7 AM Pump session 25 minutes
9 AM Pump session 25 minutes
12 PM Pump session 25 minutes
3 PM Pump session 25 minutes
6 PM Pump session 25 minutes
9 PM Pump session 25 minutes
12 AM Pump session 25 minutes
Total 175 minutes

This schedule involves pumping about every 3 hours during the day and once overnight. Each session includes setting up the pump, pumping, storing milk, and cleaningparts. In total, this schedule requires close to 3 hours a day for pumping alone.

In contrast, a typical breastfeeding schedule in the early months may look like this:

Time Nursing Session Duration
7 AM Nurse upon waking 15 minutes
9 AM Nursing session 10 minutes
12 PM Nursing session 10 minutes
3 PM Nursing session 10 minutes
6 PM Nursing session 15 minutes
9 PM Nursing session 10 minutes
12 AM Nursing session 15 minutes
Total 85 minutes

For direct nursing, feedings are done on demand when the baby shows hunger cues. Each session involves getting baby latched and nursing until full. Total daily nursing time averages about an hour and a half.

When you compare the two schedules side-by-side, pumping requires significantly more time and effort than breastfeeding. However, keep in mind that direct nursing requires the mother to be available for all feedings, while pumping provides more flexibility.

The Physical Effort of Pumping and Breastfeeding

Beyond just time, the physical effort required can also impact how tiring each method is. Here is a look at the physical demands:

Pumping:

  • Setting up pump and getting set up
  • Being attached to pump flanges for duration of pumping
  • Potential discomfort or pain from flanges
  • Remaining stationary for pumping session
  • Storing milk and cleaning pump parts after each session

Breastfeeding:

  • Getting baby latched and positioned
  • Remaining in nursing position for duration of feeding
  • Discomfort from poor latch or positioning
  • Frequent nursing sessions round-the-clock
  • Possible sore nipples, engorgement, or clogged ducts

Many mothers find the physical sensation of pumping to be more uncomfortable than direct nursing. The pump flanges can cause nipple pain or irritation over time. Plus being attached to the pump restricts movement during the session. However, others find pumping less physically taxing, especially if they have a comfortable, properly-fitted flange.

For breastfeeding, comfort levels can vary greatly depending on the individual mother and baby. Some mothers experience minimal discomfort, while others deal with issues like poor latch, frequent feedings, and nipple pain. Proper nursing positioning and support can help minimize challenges.

The Hormonal Response

The hormonal response generated by pumping and nursing also impacts how tiring each can be. Breastfeeding triggers the release of oxytocin and prolactin, hormones that promote milk production and feelings of calm and relaxation. Pumping can also trigger these hormones but usually to a lesser degree.

The oxytocin surge that comes with nursing creates a relaxation response, while pumping lacks this same effect. As a result, many mothers report feeling more fulfilled and less stressed directly nursing their babies. The hormonal response of breastfeeding can provide both physical and emotional benefits compared to pumping.

However, women respond differently and some feel they get an adequate milk ejection reflex when pumping. Much depends on the mother’s comfort and confidence with each method.

Impact on Milk Supply

Another consideration is the impact pumping and nursing each have on milk supply. Milk supply is driven by consistent removal of milk from the breasts. Both pumping and nursing stimulate milk production. However, direct nursing is generally more efficient at removing milk and signaling your body to produce more.

Exclusively pumping has the risk of decreased milk supply over time if pumping sessions are skipped or milk isn’t fully expressed. With direct nursing, the breasts never get overly full between feedings which can lead to decreased supply. Your body makes exactly as much milk as baby removes.

If milk supply is abundant, pumping may feel easier. But if supply is borderline, the extra effort to maintain it through pumping can become exhausting.

Emotional Factors

Beyond the physical aspects, there are emotional components that contribute to how tiring breastfeeding and pumping feel. Some emotional factors include:

  • Bonding – Nursing provides quality bonding time with baby that pumping lacks. This can make direct feeding more satisfying.
  • Isolation – Exclusive pumping can feel isolating, sitting attached to a machine instead of holding the baby.
  • Restriction – Needing to pump frequently restricts daily activities and outings.
  • Motivation – Greater motivation to directly nurse baby may help mothers push through challenges.
  • Pressure – Stress about milk supply may make pumping feel like a chore.

The emotional impact of pumping vs breastfeeding is unique for every mom. But most report feeling a higher level of satisfaction and fulfillment from the closeness of nursing their baby.

Tips to Make Pumping and Breastfeeding Easier

If you find pumping or breastfeeding to be overly challenging or tiring, there are things you can do to help:

For Pumping:

  • Invest in a high-quality double electric pump to save time
  • Limit pumping sessions to 15-20 minutes to avoid excess wear and tear on nipples
  • Add flange lubricant or warm compresses to increase comfort
  • Massage breasts while pumping to aid let-down reflex
  • Look at photos of baby to promote milk flow
  • Stay hydrated and pump after feeding baby to take advantage of oxytocin

For Breastfeeding:

  • Use laid-back/biological nurturing positions to allow baby control latch
  • Keep baby skin-to-skin as much as possible
  • Breastfeed lying down to rest while nursing
  • Use breast compression and massage while nursing
  • Wear comfortable nursing bras and clothing
  • Apply lanolin after feeds to soothe nipples

Finding ways to maximize comfort and efficiency with both methods can help reduce frustration and fatigue. Having support from a lactation consultant or peers can also make the experience less tiring.

Conclusion

While pumping gives mothers more flexibility, direct breastfeeding offers superior convenience and efficiency in most cases. The time commitment, physical demands, and emotional factors involved generally make exclusive pumping more exhausting for mothers. However, a combination of pumping and nursing as needed allows moms to get the best of both methods.

There is no definitive answer on whether pumping or nursing is more tiring. Each mother and baby will have a different experience based on many individual factors. Being educated on the pros and cons of both can help mothers make the choice that best meets their own needs and lifestyle. Finding a balance that works and gets baby the breast milk they need is the ultimate goal.