Skip to Content

What is the difference between chocolate cake and German chocolate cake?

Quick Answer

The main differences between chocolate cake and German chocolate cake are:

  • Chocolate cake is made with regular baking chocolate while German chocolate cake is made with German sweet chocolate.
  • German chocolate cake contains coconut and pecans while chocolate cake does not.
  • Chocolate cake typically only has chocolate in the actual cake while German chocolate cake has chocolate in the cake as well as the frosting.
  • German chocolate cake was named after Samuel German who created a type of sweet baking chocolate, but it does not actually originate from Germany.

What is Chocolate Cake?

Chocolate cake is a classic cake flavor made by adding melted chocolate or cocoa powder to vanilla cake batter. It originated in the United States in the 19th century and rose to popularity as chocolate became more accessible.

The key ingredients in chocolate cake are:

  • All-purpose flour – The base of the cake
  • Sugar – Sweetens the cake
  • Eggs – Helps bind the cake and add moisture
  • Butter or oil – Adds moisture and richness
  • Milk – Helps make the cake tender and moist
  • Baking soda & powder – Helps the cake rise
  • Salt – Enhances the chocolate flavor
  • Vanilla – Brings out the chocolate taste
  • Cocoa powder or melted chocolate – Provides the chocolate flavor

The baking process for chocolate cake is:

1. Whisk together dry ingredients like flour, cocoa powder, salt, baking soda.
2. In another bowl, cream together butter and sugar.
3. Add in eggs one at a time, mixing well after each addition.
4. Alternate adding some of the dry ingredients and milk to the wet ingredients.
5. Mix just until combined, avoid overmixing.
6. Pour batter into greased cake pans and bake at 350°F for 30-40 minutes.
7. Check for doneness and allow to cool completely before frosting.

The cake is very moist, rich and fudgy. It can be enjoyed plain, with just a dusting of powdered sugar, or frosted with chocolate buttercream or ganache. It’s a versatile base for many cake flavors and shapes like cupcakes, sheet cakes, layered cakes and more.

Types of Chocolate Cake

There are several popular variations of chocolate cake:

  • Dark Chocolate Cake – Made solely with dark cocoa powder for an intense chocolate flavor.
  • German Chocolate Cake – Contains coconut-pecan filling and frosting.
  • Chocolate Fudge Cake – Extra moist and fudgy from more chocolate.
  • Flourless Chocolate Cake – Denser and richer from no flour.
  • Molten Lava Cake – Oozy, melted center.
  • Black Forest Cake – Layers of chocolate cake and whipped cream.

What is German Chocolate Cake?

German chocolate cake originated in America, despite its name. It’s named after Sam German, who developed a type of sweetened baking chocolate in 1852. Here is some background on the popular cake:

  • It first appeared in a Texas newspaper in 1957 and became popular nationwide.
  • The cake uses German sweet chocolate, which contains milk and sugar.
  • It features coconut-pecan frosting and filling between layers.
  • The frosting ingredients usually include butter, evaporated milk, coconut, and pecans.
  • German sweet chocolate gives it a sweeter, milder chocolate taste.
  • It’s richer, heavier, and more decadent than regular chocolate cake.

German chocolate cake contains:

  • All-purpose flour
  • Granulated sugar
  • Eggs
  • Butter
  • Milk
  • German sweet chocolate
  • Baking soda and powder
  • Salt
  • Vanilla extract
  • Coconut and pecans for filling/frosting

The baking method is very similar to regular chocolate cake. The main difference is that the melted German chocolate is used in place of regular baking chocolate.

German Chocolate Cake Baking Process:

1. Whisk flour, baking soda, salt.
2. Beat butter and sugar until fluffy.
3. Add eggs one at a time.
4. Stir in melted German chocolate and vanilla.
5. Alternate adding dry ingredients and milk to batter.
6. Pour into greased cake pans and bake.
7. Cool completely and assemble cake layers with coconut-pecan filling/frosting.

Difference Between Chocolate Cake and German Chocolate Cake

While both cakes are chocolatey and delicious, there are some key differences between regular chocolate cake and German chocolate cake:

Chocolate

Chocolate Cake German Chocolate Cake
Uses regular unsweetened baking chocolate or cocoa powder Uses German sweet chocolate which contains milk and sugar
Deep, bittersweet chocolate flavor Milder, sweeter chocolate taste

Texture

Chocolate Cake German Chocolate Cake
Very moist and fudgy cake crumb Richer and denser texture
Soft, silky frosting Coconut-pecan frosting adds crunchy texture

Flavors

Chocolate Cake German Chocolate Cake
Showcases pure chocolate flavor Coconut and pecans add sweetness
Enjoyable on its own Frosting/filling is integral to the flavor

Composition

Chocolate Cake German Chocolate Cake
Typically 2-3 cake layers filled and frosted At least 4 thin layers filled and frosted
Chocolate only used in cake itself Chocolate in cake and frosting

Origin

Chocolate Cake German Chocolate Cake
Unknown exact origins Invented in America in 1957
Does not come from Germany Named after Sam German – does not come from Germany

Similarities Between Chocolate Cake and German Chocolate Cake

While they have distinct differences, chocolate cake and German chocolate cake do share some common traits:

  • Both are chocolate-based cakes made with cocoa powder or chocolate
  • Each contains ingredients like flour, butter, eggs, milk, baking soda/powder
  • They rely on chocolate to provide the primary flavor
  • Creamy frosting or ganache is typically used on both cakes
  • Layers are often filled with chocolate frosting for more decadence
  • Many steps of the baking process are the same
  • They are popular choices for birthday cakes
  • Can be made into cupcakes, sheet cakes and other forms

So in summary, while German chocolate cake incorporates more unique elements like coconut and pecans, both it and regular chocolate cake are tasty, chocolatey celebratory cakes loved by many!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is German chocolate cake from Germany?

No, German chocolate cake was invented in America and named after Sam German, who created the type of sweet chocolate used in the cake. It does not actually come from Germany.

What’s the difference in taste?

Chocolate cake has a deep, bittersweet chocolate flavor while German chocolate cake is milder and sweeter due to the German sweet chocolate and coconut-pecan frosting.

Can you make substitutions between the two cakes?

You can substitute regular baking chocolate in place of German chocolate when making German chocolate cake, but the flavor will be more intense. You can also add coconut and pecans to chocolate cake, but the textures would not be quite the same.

Which cake is more challenging to bake?

German chocolate cake typically has more components with the coconut-pecan frosting, so it can be slightly more work. However, both cakes are beginner-friendly baking recipes.

What occasions are the cakes best for?

Both cakes are perfect for birthdays, holidays, and special occasions. Chocolate cake can work for everyday desserts as well. German chocolate cake tends to be more celebratory.

Conclusion

German chocolate cake and regular chocolate cake are two of the most beloved chocolate cakes. While they are both chocolate-based cakes, German chocolate cake sets itself apart with the signature coconut-pecan frosting and filling, use of German sweet chocolate for a milder flavor, and extra layers making it more decadent. However, chocolate cake is the simpler classic option allowing the rich chocolate taste to take center stage. So whether you prefer the pure chocolate flavor or the sweeter, tropical twist, both cakes make for a perfect special occasion dessert!