Skip to Content

What treasure is still lost at sea?

For centuries, the oceans have beckoned explorers with promises of adventure and riches. Shipwrecks carrying precious cargo have long sparked fascination and fevered searches. Even today, sunken treasures worth billions may still be out there somewhere beneath the waves. Here’s a look at some of history’s most famous and valuable shipwrecks that have never been recovered.

The Flor de la Mar Treasure

The Flor de la Mar was a Portuguese carrack that sank in a storm in 1511 while returning from conquering Malacca on the Malay Peninsula. Commanded by Alfonso de Albuquerque, the ship carried an enormous treasure hoard looted from Malacca. Estimates of the trove’s worth range wildly from $2 billion to $4 billion in today’s dollars. It included gold, silver, precious gems, and religious artifacts. Some experts believe it may have carried the largest trove of treasures ever lost at sea. But despite numerous searches, the wreck has never been found. Its location remains one of history’s biggest maritime mysteries.

Why the Wreck Can’t Be Found

The Flor de la Mar was lost in a storm off the coast of Sumatra. Over the years, scholars have proposed various theories on where the wreck may lie. Unfortunately, the Sumatran coast lacks extensive written records from that era describing the ship’s route. And the Flor de la Mar’s treasures may have shifted the wreckage or buried it under layers of sand. These factors make pinpointing its location extremely difficult. But historians agree that if found, the riches would be priceless.

The Treasure of Lima

In 1820, Lima, Peru was on the cusp of revolting against Spanish rule. To keep riches safe, Spanish officials loaded a ship with gold, silver and jewels worth up to $60 million. But it never made it to Mexico for safekeeping. Instead, pirates seized the ship, looted some of the treasure and then scuttled the vessel. According to legend, the loot lies buried on Cocos Island off the coast of Costa Rica. Since the 19th century, over 300 expeditions have searched there. But apart from recovering a handful of gold coins, the bulk remains at large.

Why the Hoard Eludes Hunters

Cocos Island’s terrain makes searching extremely difficult. Its jungles are thick and mountainous, with torrential rains. Landslides also frequently reshuffle the landscape. Some experts believe the treasure wasn’t even buried there. And claims have emerged that it was recovered long ago. However, many remain undeterred. The allure of this lost fortune continues to entrance adventurers and explorers.

The Nuestra Señora de Atocha

In 1622, the Spanish galleon Nuestra Señora de Atocha was heading back to Spain when it sank off the Florida Keys. On board were riches from Spanish colonies in South America. Initial salvage attempts recovered some artifacts, but most of the trove remained lost. In 1985, treasure hunter Mel Fisher unearthed the ship’s main treasure hoard after years of searching. The impressive haul included over 1,000 silver coins, gold jewelry and Colombian emeralds. Experts value the collection at over $400 million. However, Fisher believed more treasure may still be buried nearby.

Unrecovered Riches

Before sinking, the Atocha was part of a fleet carrying immense wealth. When it went down, a second ship – the Santa Margarita – rescued the Atocha’s crew and transferred its cargo. Mel Fisher’s team located the Santa Margarita wreck in 1980. But no treasure was found, suggesting it may still lie near the Atocha. In addition, the manifests show the Atocha carried far more gold and jewels than Fisher uncovered. Despite his passing in 1998, his family maintains the quest to find the lost fortunes.

Blackbeard’s Treasure

In 1718, the notorious English pirate Blackbeard blockaded the port of Charleston, South Carolina. He ransomed the port for medical supplies and then released his hostages. Shortly after, he deliberately grounded his flagship – the Queen Anne’s Revenge – on a sandbar. Most historians believe Blackbeard intentionally scuttled the vessel to reduce his crew size and hide treasure on board. While remnants of the ship have been recovered, more than three centuries later, tales of its hidden gold and contraband persist.

The Allure of Pirate Plunder

Recovering artifacts like cannons and anchors from the Queen Anne’s Revenge provides insight into early 18th-century piracy. They reveal Blackbeard’s firepower and readiness for battle. However, treasure is what really captures public imagination. No one knows for sure whether unfound riches remain or if Blackbeard recovered it all. Still, the possibility helps cement Blackbeard’s legendary status. The lore of pirates hoarding troves of ill-gotten wealth continues to fascinate.

The Lost Treasures of Lake Guatavita

High in Colombia’s Andes mountains lies Lake Guatavita. It is the site of a legendary treasure trove resting beneath its waters. In pre-Columbian times, the native Muisca people ritualistically sprayed gold dust into the lake as offerings. They also submerged gold and emerald jewelry during ceremonies. Attempts to drain the lake over the centuries yielded limited artifacts. But widespread looting makes it difficult to know all that remains lost.

Estimate of Treasure’s Worth Key Facts
$10 million to $300 million Muisca artifacts on display in the Gold Museum, Bogota
Pieces made of tumbaga (gold alloy) Lake drainage attempts in 1580 and 1898
Emeralds, gold crowns, tunjos (figurines) Colombian government now protects the site

While individual treasure hunters are banned, searches can resume if technology improves. However, the lake’s remote location and depth continue to keep its secrets hidden.

La Salle’s Lost French Fleet

In 1685, the French explorer Robert de La Salle led an expedition to establish a colony in Louisiana. He set sail from France with four ships and 300 colonists. During the voyage, pirates attacked two ships, killing crew and colonists. After reaching the Gulf of Mexico, La Salle mistakenly grounded a third ship on the Texas coast. With one vessel left, he led a mission to find the Mississippi River by canoe but was murdered by his men. The final ship sank soon after. Modern-day searches have found remnants of the other three ships. However, the wreck that likely holds the most treasure has never been recovered.

Unfound Riches Off the Texas Coast

The only ship of La Salle’s fleet not plundered by pirates was La Belle, his primary supply vessel. In 1995, archaeologists found the wreck but left the unique artifacts intact. Experts believe its cargo holds fine wares like glass crystal, mirrors, tableware and tools meant to impress native tribes and establish trade. Also on board were material goods and presents from King Louis XIV. The shipwreck’s location makes salvaging its cultural treasures challenging. But it offers a unique time capsule into France’s failed 17th century colonization efforts.

The SS Central America

The SS Central America was a steamship ferrying fortune seekers to California during the Gold Rush. In 1857, it sank in a hurricane off North Carolina’s coast with around 580 passengers and a major shipment of gold on board. Initial recovery attempts salvaged only a fraction of the wreckage along with $1.2 million of the gold haul. In 1988, the Columbus-America Discovery Group found the wreck site buried 7,200 feet down. They ultimately recovered gold bars and coins valued at over $100 million.

Gold treasure recovered Estimated gold still missing
15 tons of gold ingots and nuggets Approx. 9-11 additional tons
Over 5,000 $20 Double Eagle gold coins Over 400 passengers were reportedly carrying gold

Legal disputes halted further salvage efforts. Since then, advances in underwater archaeology and robotics may make recovering more of the remaining fortune possible.

The Wreck of the Concepción

In 1641, the Spanish galleon Concepción sunk during a storm near the Silver Shoals off Hispaniola. It was headed to Spain carrying gold, silver, gems, jewels and other riches looted from the Americas. Initial salvage attempts brought up stones, artifacts and precious ore. But efforts stopped when Spain ceded Hispaniola to France in 1697. In 1978, American widow and financier Betty Seaton located the wreck site but died before recovering the fortune. Estimates place the value as high as $2 billion.

Preserved Treasure in Deep Waters

The Concepción lies up to 40 feet beneath the seabed in deep waters, helping preserve its contents. The ship remained forgotten until William Phips found it in 1687, recovering over 37,000 pesos in silver and gold. But locating it again proved elusive. When Seaton found it centuries later, Tropical Storm Danielle halted her operations. Legal battles have deterred subsequent search attempts. However, scientists compare the wreck’s potential richness to Spanish galleons like the Atocha and the Santa Margarita.

The Lost 1715 Treasure Fleet

The 1715 treasure fleet consisted of 12 Spanish ships carrying chests of gold, silver, emeralds and jewelry from the Caribbean to Spain. In July 1715, all 12 vessels sank during a hurricane off Florida’s east coast. Native tribes living in the area quickly began salvaging the ships. But eight heavily laden wrecks have never been found. Their reputed worth lies between $550 million to $4 billion. Since then, numerous pirate tales mentioning the treasure trove have emerged.

Major Finds Significant Evidence
1928: Gold and emeralds recovered from north of Vero Beach 1961: Coins and artifacts found on Sebastian Beach
1972: $30,000 worth of coins found off Fort Pierce 2008: Anchor retrieved 45 miles north of West Palm Beach

While recoveries have been made, archaeologists believe the bulk of the treasure remains at the primary wreck sites. Their exact location is unclear, as storms can scatter shipwrecks over a wide area. Advanced sonar scanning continues the hunt.

Treasure of theRMS Republic

The RMS Republic sank during a collision with another vessel in 1909 about 100 miles off Nantucket, Massachusetts. Constructed in 1903, it was state-of-the-art and the largest passenger steamer of its time. While all passengers were saved, the Republic took an estimated $750,000 in gold coins to the ocean floor. This would equal around $20 million today. Insurance companies ran salvage operations, but rough seas, expenses and new federal laws hindered their efforts.

Rediscovering the Wreck Site

The RMS Republic briefly held the title of the richest shipwreck in the world. But its location became lost over time. In 1981, new sonar technology helped identify the wreckage 250 feet down. In 2003, it became the first shipwreck to be probed using remotely operated vehicles. The ship lies upright and largely intact, with some salvageable gold still believed to be on board. While access is restricted, the Republic serves as a unique time capsule of the Gilded Age.


Sunken treasures have enthralled adventurers and explorers for centuries. They offer time portals into bygone eras and the societies that created them. While legal hurdles and cost challenges often interfere with recoveries, risks also exist of plundering cultural heritage sites and sacred indigenous zones. Regardless, lost fortunes beneath the waves continue to spark popular fascination and feed legends. With advancing technologies, the chances remain that even more of these elusive underwater troves may see the light of day once more.