Skip to Content

Which gender dog makes a better pet?

When it comes to choosing a dog as a pet, one of the first questions that comes to mind is whether a male or female dog makes a better companion. Both genders have their own unique qualities and considerations when deciding which sex would be better for your lifestyle and preferences.

Personality Differences Between Male and Female Dogs

There are some general personality differences between male and female dogs that are important to keep in mind. Females tend to be more independent, territorial, and mature faster than males. They go into heat twice a year and can have mood swings and behavioral changes during this time. Males are often more affectionate, exuberant, goofy, and slower to mature. They are also more likely to mark their territory by urinating around the house. However, these distinctions are not necessarily true for all dogs. Much depends on how the dog was socialized and trained. Here is a breakdown of some key personality differences:

Male Dogs Female Dogs
Goofy, puppyish behavior More serious, dignified
More affectionate, people-oriented Somewhat more aloof, independent
Slower to mature Matures faster
Higher energy, exuberant Lower key energy
Mark territory by urinating Territorial around nesting areas
Less aggressive toward other dogs More dog aggression, fights

However, these are just generalizations. A dog’s individual temperament depends on genetics, socialization, training, and handling.

Trainability Differences

When it comes to trainability, female dogs tend to be easier to train and more responsive to commands. They mature faster so they can be housetrained at an earlier age. Females can focus better than males, who get more easily distracted and want to play instead of train. Here are some key trainability differences:

Male Dogs Female Dogs
Easily distracted Better able to focus
May challenge owner’s authority Aim to please owners
Slower to housetrain Quicker to housetrain
Harder time obeying Easier time following commands
Forget training when excited Retain training better

However, a dog’s trainability also depends on breed, socialization, and training methods used. Both genders can be trained with consistency, patience and positive reinforcement.

Activity Level Differences

In general, male dogs tend to have higher energy levels and require more physical activity and exercise than females. Intact males especially have more testosterone fueling their high energy. Females are often calmer and do not require quite as much vigorous exercise. Here are some activity differences:

Male Dogs Female Dogs
Higher energy, needs more exercise Lower key energy
Needs daily vigorous exercise Moderate exercise sufficient
Higher prey drive Less driven to chase
Inquisitive, likes exploring Lower wanderlust impulse
Can be hyperactive if bored Better able to settle, less hyper

However, these activity differences depend greatly on breed. Some female breeds have energy equal to any male. An individual dog’s temperament plays a big role too.

Health and Care Differences

There are some health and care considerations that differ between male and female dogs as well. Females go into heat twice per year during which time they bleed and need to be kept away from males. They can also develop medical issues associated with hormones and reproduction. Males are predisposed to certain urinary tract conditions. Here are some other health differences:

Male Dogs Female Dogs
Leg hikes to urinate Squats to urinate
Prone to urinary obstructions Vulnerable to Pyometra
Higher risk of some cancers Mammary tumors risk
Aggression if not neutered Aggression when in heat
Neutering reduces roaming Spaying prevents heat cycles

Routine wellness care, spay/neuter, socialization and training can help keep both genders healthy and well-behaved.

Which Gender Makes a Better Pet?

When considering which gender dog makes the better pet, there are good reasons for both. Females are often recommended for first-time owners since they mature faster, are easier to train, and are less active. However, individual temperament is more important than gender. Here are some general guidelines:

  • Families with young kids may prefer a female due to less rambunctiousness.
  • Singles and seniors may find loyal, affectionate males ideal.
  • Active households may enjoy a high energy male.
  • Experienced owners do well with either gender.
  • Both need training, socializing and outlet for energy.
  • Spay/neuter reduces hormone-driven behaviors.
  • Personality, energy level and breed matter most.

The most important factors in choosing a pet are providing proper training, socialization, exercise and veterinary care. Both male and female dogs can make wonderful companions when their needs are met. Discuss your lifestyle and preferences with breeders, shelters and rescue groups to determine which gender dog would make the best fit.

Tips for Living with Male Dogs

Here are some tips for living harmoniously with a male dog:

  • Neuter your male dog by 6-12 months to decrease roaming, marking and aggression.
  • Provide daily vigorous exercise to burn off energy.
  • Use positive reinforcement training for best results.
  • Give them “jobs” to do like carrying packs on walks.
  • Provide interactive puzzle toys to occupy them.
  • Interrupt and correct excessive barking.
  • Teach them commands like “settle” to calm down.
  • Socialize them extensively to curb aggressive tendencies.
  • Be patient but firm during their slower maturity phase.
  • Learn what triggers excitable behavior and manage those situations.

Tips for Living with Female Dogs

Here are some pointers for co-existing smoothly with a female dog:

  • Spay your female around 6 months old to prevent heat cycles.
  • Keep intact females separate from males when in heat.
  • Teach good manners from puppyhood before bad habits form.
  • Provide daily walks and playtime, but less intensive exercise needed.
  • Giveaccess to quiet places she can retreat to when needed.
  • Discourage possessive behavior around food, toys and sleeping areas.
  • Socialize extensively to reduce territorial guarding against people and dogs.
  • Reward her often for following commands and being obedient.
  • Provide mental stimulation with food puzzles, Kongs, training sessions.
  • Remain calm but firm in enforcing rules.


In conclusion, there are some general differences between male and female dogs in terms of energy level, trainability, health considerations and personality. However, choosing the gender that will make the best pet depends largely on your lifestyle, experience and preferences. While female dogs tend to be easier for new owners, with proper training, socializing and care, both male and female dogs can make delightful companions. The most important factors are understanding the needs of the individual dog and providing appropriate care to bring out their best qualities.