Who can't be godparents?

Choosing godparents for your child is an important decision. Godparents play a special role in supporting the spiritual development of a child. When selecting godparents, most churches have requirements that need to be met. Understanding who is excluded from being godparents can help guide the selection process.

Table of Contents

What are the responsibilities of godparents?

Godparents have a few key responsibilities when taking on this important role:

Provide spiritual guidance and support to the child
Ensure the child is raised in the faith and attends church services
Be a good role model by leading a Christian lifestyle

Offer mentorship as the child grows up
Give the child a gift of a bible or other spiritual item
Attend the baptism ceremony and confess faith on behalf of the child

Given these meaningful duties, parents must choose godparents who are up to the task and committed to fulfilling their obligations. The godparents should be individuals who are steadfast in their own faith and willing to take interest in the child’s spiritual upbringing.

What are the typical church rules on godparents?

While specific regulations can vary by denomination, most churches have a standard set of criteria for who may serve as godparents:

Godparents must be baptized and confirmed in the faith themselves.

They must be actively practicing Christians who attend church regularly.
They should be at least 16 years old or older.
Godparents must set an example of moral character and integrity.

Married godparents should be in a church-approved marriage.
Godparents cannot be the biological parents of the child.
Most churches require at least one godparent be Catholic for a Catholic baptism.

These rules help ensure godparents are spiritually prepared for the task at hand and able to carry out their duties faithfully. Parents must keep these standards in mind when selecting godparents for their child’s baptism.

Why are parents excluded from being godparents?

One notable exclusion is that biological parents cannot serve as godparents for their own children. There are a few reasons behind this prohibition:

Godparents are meant to provide spiritual guidance separate from the parents. As the child’s primary caregivers, parents already have an active role in teaching faith.

Having godparents adds another layer of support and mentorship for the child’s religious growth.
Godparents should have enough distance to take an objective view and guide the parents themselves if needed.
Serving as godparents creates a special spiritual bond beyond the biological bond between parent and child.

Parents have the duty of raising their children in the church. Godparents complement this by contributing spiritual support from outside the family.

Why are non-Christians and lapsed Christians excluded?

Active, faithful Christians make the best godparent candidates. Individuals who do not meet this requirement are restricted for a few reasons:

Godparents must set a strong Christian example for the godchild to follow.

They need to encourage and model Christian values and behavior.
A basic knowledge of the faith is required to provide religious instruction.
Without faith themselves, they lack the ability to nurture faith in the godchild.

The godchild can be confused by hypocrisy or indifference to religion.

A godparent should have a passion for their own faith in order to inspire passion in their godchild’s spiritual life. Lukewarm or non-believing godparents fail to offer this.

Why are minors and young people restricted from being godparents?

While godparents are often family members or friends, mature adults are better equipped for this role. Limitations are placed on minors and young people becoming godparents due to:

Godparents need life experience and wisdom to provide guidance.
Younger godparents may lack the maturity or commitment expected.
Elders are seen as stronger spiritual role models.

Their own faith and habits are still developing.
They likely do not have capability to support the child financially if ever needed.
Responsibilities like attending the baptism or dedication service may be difficult for minors.

While no specific age cutoff prohibits being a godparent, churches encourage selecting adults who are more stable in faith and lifestyle.

Why are non-Christians prohibited from being godparents?

Here are the main reasons someone of a different faith, or no faith at all, could not serve as a godparent:

Godparents must believe in the trinity – God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit.

They need to be baptized themselves and active in a Christian church.
Other faiths hold different beliefs which conflict with Christian teaching.
Without accepting Christian beliefs, they cannot make the profession of faith required.

It can confuse a child’s spiritual development to have a godparent of a different religion.
Supporting someone else’s participation in a different religion may go against their own beliefs.

Being a godparent requires taking vows to raise the child in Christian faith. This would compromise the integrity of someone whose spiritual beliefs differ.

Why are people married outside the church restricted from being godparents?

Typically, godparents must be in a valid Christian marriage recognized by the church. Reasons for excluding those in civil or non-Christian marriages include:

Marriage is an important sacrament and reflection of Christian devotion.
Godparents should model a commitment to church-approved marriage.

An unmarried lifestyle goes against Christian values of marriage and family.
Without following their own church’s rules, they lack credibility as spiritual role models.
It seems hypocritical to make promises supporting a child’s faith when disregarding the same church’s rules.

Their spiritual authority is undermined by not having a marriage sanctified by the church.

For a godparent to be seen as a pillar of the faith, following sacraments like marriage is usually required by churches.

Why are members of certain groups like cults or sects excluded?

Here is why members of controversial groups viewed as cults or sects are restricted from serving as godparents:

These groups hold unorthodox beliefs diverging from Christian teachings.
Godparents must adhere to standard church doctrine and principles.
The practices and interpretations of some groups are seen as dangerous or extreme.

Their spiritual authority to instruct a child is not accepted by traditional churches.
Parents do not want children exposed to beliefs that contradict their own faith.
There are fears of children being recruited or indoctrinated by these groups.

Overall, fringe organizations are barred from having members serve as godparents to avoid any promotion of unorthodox ideology to impressionable children.

Why are notorious sinners and public sinners barred from godparenthood?

Those known for living in open defiance of Christian morality cannot serve as godparents due to:

Godparents must be virtuous role models for the godchild.

They should epitomize Christian values in their speech, actions, and lifestyle.
Notorious sinners lack credibility as ethical and spiritual guides.
Their poor example can negatively influence the godchild’s character.

Public scandal diminishes their reputation and authority.
Churches avoid giving implicit approval of sin by allowing them this honor.

While godparents should help others grow in faith, unrepentant notorious sinners fail to meet the moral standards expected of godparents.

Why are clergy and monks/nuns excluded from godparenthood?

Here are some reasons why members of the clergy and monastic orders may be prohibited from serving as godparents:

They have spiritual duties occupying much of their time and attention.
Monks and nuns are focused on contemplative prayer and may be cloistered.

Their lifestyles do not model family life in the secular world.
Godparents should offer a perspective connecting the church and larger society.
Developing close relationships with individual children may be seen as creating favoritism.

They already have a special relationship with all children by virtue of ministry.

Godparents provide spiritual nurturing distinct from a priest or nun’s official church role. Their unique guidance completes the child’s support system.

Can non-Catholics be godparents for Catholic baptisms?

For baptisms in the Catholic church, godparents must meet additional requirements:

At least one godparent must be an actively practicing Catholic.
They must be fully initiated in the faith themselves, having received baptism, first communion, and confirmation.
Godparents must be at least 16 years old.

If married, they must be in a marriage recognized as valid by the Catholic church.
Godparents take an oath swearing to fulfill their obligations to help raise the child Catholic.

While non-Catholic Christians may serve as “Christian Witnesses” alongside a Catholic godparent, the church requires at least one devout Catholic godparent to represent the faith.

Can non-Catholic relatives or friends serve as Christian Witnesses?

Yes, Christian Witnesses who are non-Catholic can supplement the Catholic godparent. Requirements for Christian Witnesses include:

They should be a baptized non-Catholic Christian.
Only one male or female Christian Witness is permitted.

If married, they must be in a marriage recognized as valid by the Catholic church.
They may accompany the child along with the Catholic godparent during the ceremony.
They make no formal oath but stand as a moral support to the child.

While lacking the full spiritual authority of a Catholic godparent, Christian Witnesses can still provide an important supporting role model.

Can a Catholic serve as a godparent for non-Catholic baptisms?

Yes, Catholics can serve as godparents for many Protestant denominations. Typical requirements Protestant churches have for godparents include:

Godparents should be baptized active Christians.

They should be regular churchgoers in good standing.
Godparents must set an example of Christian values.
They should be mature adults, often over 18 years old.

If married, they should be in a Christian marriage recognized by the church.
They may need to affirm baptismal vows and faith on behalf of the child.

As baptized Christians willing to nurture a child’s spiritual growth, Catholics can often qualify as godparents in many Protestant circles.

Can non-practicing Catholics or lapsed Catholics be godparents?

A Catholic cannot serve as godparent if they lack active faith and church participation. Reasons include:

Godparents must be committed to modeling Catholic values.
They should attend Mass regularly and live according to church teaching.

Inactive Catholics cannot fulfill promises to encourage the child’s Catholic faith.
Lapsed Catholics fail to meet the basic standards expected of godparents.
The child needs godparents who are strong spiritual role models.

Parents should select godparents still passionate about their Catholic identity.

Despite baptism, those who have strayed from the church or lost enthusiasm for their faith make poor godparent selections when actively practicing Catholics are required.

Can divorced Catholics serve as godparents?

Whether a divorced Catholic can be a godparent depends on circumstances:

If civilly divorced but not remarried, and faith remains strong, they may still qualify.
However, if they have remarried outside the Catholic church, eligibility is lost.
An annulment dissolving the first union may allow remarriage and godparenthood.

Divorcees adhering to church rules likely retain spiritual standing.
But disregard of Catholic marriage laws prevents serving as godparents.

Provided the divorced person upholds marriage sacrament norms, divorce alone does not prohibit being a godparent. But remarriage outside church approval causes disqualification.

Can a child have more than one godparent?

It is common for children to have multiple godparents with different types of relationships:

Catholic tradition has one godfather and one godmother as the ideal pair of godparents.
Some Protestant churches also follow this one godfather and godmother model.

Having godparents of both genders provides balance and diverse perspectives.
But other Protestant circles allow flexibility in the godparent gender makeup.
So a child may have two godfathers or two godmothers instead of one of each gender.

Some families opt to have several sets of godparents, with four to six godparents altogether.

There is room for customization based on a family’s wishes and their church’s allowances on godparent gender and numbers.

Is there a maximum number of godparents allowed?

Limits on godparent numbers include:

In the Catholic church, only two godparents are permitted – one male and one female.
Protestant churches often allow between two and four godparents.
No matter the denomination, more than six godparents is rare.

Too many godparents can become impractical.
A balance needs to be struck between diverse support and unrealistic expectations.
The role risks being diluted if divided across too many people.

Couples should weigh the benefits of an extra godparent against spreading the responsibilities too thin.

Can relatives serve as godparents?

Godparents are very often relatives of the child. Reasons family members make natural choices include:

Close relatives are able to develop tight, lasting bonds with the child.

They share family background and values with the parents.
Relatives may reside nearby and see the child regularly at family gatherings.
It feels meaningful and special to include relatives in this role.

Family is central to a child’s support system.
Kinship ties strengthen the godparent-godchild relationship.

Relatives who exhibit strong Christian faith make excellent candidates who will take a special interest in their little relative.

What relatives are most commonly selected as godparents?

The most popular relatives considered for godparents include:

Siblings of the parents
Cousins such as the child’s aunts/uncles

The child’s grandparents
Sometimes the child’s aunts/uncles
Occasionally the parents’ cousins who are the child’s great aunts/uncles

Siblings of the parents and the grandparents tend to be top choices to fulfill this meaningful family role.

Can family friends or other non-relatives serve as godparents?

Close family friends often serve as godparents. Reasons friends make good godparent choices include:

Friends may know the parents well and share similar values.

Longtime friends offer a trusted, familiar presence in the child’s life.
Friends treat the child with special love as if extended family.
They bring an “aunt” or “uncle” type relationship.

Friends provide spiritual guidance from outside the biological family.
The parents feel comfortable entrusting friends to nurture faith.

Devout, caring friends make excellent godparent options to expose children to spiritual role models beyond their relatives.

Can someone with no religion be a godparent?

It is very uncommon for someone with no religion or atheist beliefs to become a godparent. Obstacles include:

Godparents must make sincere Christian faith promises on behalf of the child.
They need to model faith in action and have knowledge of the religion.
Without faith themselves, they cannot nurture it in the godchild.
They may lack commitment to fulfill expected religious duties.
Their lack of belief contradicts the role of instilling religious values.
Parents want godparents to reinforce, not contradict, their own spiritual beliefs.

An atheist would struggle to fulfill the inherently religious expectations central to the godparent’s role.

Can agnostics or those with unsure faith serve as godparents?

Churches tend to exclude agnostics and the spiritually uncertain as godparents because:

Godparents need established faith to make baptismal promises to raise the child Christian.
They should have strong conviction in their spiritual beliefs.
Doubting or nominal Christians lack sufficient religious zeal.
Their ambivalence could fail to inspire passionate faith in the godchild.
Parents prefer godparents with certainty in their beliefs.
Their unsure faith raises concerns over fulfilling godparent obligations.

While agnostics have morals, their hesitation to fully embrace religion disqualifies them from leading a child’s faithful upbringing.

Can single or unmarried individuals become godparents?

Here are guidelines on single godparents:

Most churches welcome single godparents provided they meet all other criteria.
Their marital status alone does not prohibit serving in this role.
They should demonstrate a responsible, ethical lifestyle.
Single parents may have concern over modeling family life.
What matters most is devout faith and suitability as a mentor.
Marriage may show greater maturity but is not always required.

Churches evaluate single godparent candidates primarily on the strength of their Christian spirituality and virtues.

Conclusion

Selecting godparents for a child is an exciting chance to surround them with inspiring spiritual guides. While churches exclude certain types of candidates from serving in this role, there are still many devout, loving people who can be chosen. With some thoughtfulness about godparent requirements, parents can find special mentors to nurture their child’s faith journey.