Skip to Content

Should you trust the voice in your head?

We all have an inner voice inside our heads that provides commentary on our lives. This voice can offer wisdom and guidance, but it can also criticize and doubt us. So should you listen to and trust this inner voice, or dismiss it? Here’s an in-depth look at the pros and cons of trusting that voice inside your head.

The Potential Benefits of Listening to Your Inner Voice

Here are some potential upsides of listening to the voice inside your head:

  • It can provide helpful intuition – That inner voice often seems to know what’s best for you, intuitively guiding you toward wise decisions.
  • It offers an honest perspective – The inner voice will call out your faults and flaws, offering an unfiltered assessment of your behavior.
  • It can motivate and encourage – During challenging times, the inner voice can provide inspiration to keep you going.
  • It supports self-reflection – Listening to your self-talk can promote understanding of your deepest thoughts and beliefs.
  • It’s always there for you – While outer voices come and go, your inner voice is a constant companion.

In many cases, paying attention to your self-talk and inner wisdom can provide advantages. The voice inside your head arises from your deepest self, offering intuition and insight to guide your way.

The Potential Downsides of Listening to Your Inner Voice

However, there are also some potential pitfalls of listening too closely to that inner voice:

  • It can be overly critical – For some people, the inner voice tends toward negative self-talk rather than positive motivation.
  • It may catastrophize and assume the worst – The inner voice can jump to dire “what if” scenarios that are unlikely to occur.
  • It can undermine self-confidence – Harsh self-criticism from your inner voice can contribute to self-doubt.
  • It can resist helpful change – Growth often requires moving beyond your comfort zone, which the inner voice may resist.
  • It sometimes lies – Your inner voice may attribute failures to stable character flaws rather than situational factors.

In short, while the inner voice arises from your subconscious, it is not infallible. Sometimes it provides faulty commentary and resistance to self-improvement. So blindly following its lead is not always wise.

When to Trust – And When to Question – What the Inner Voice Says

Because the inner voice has both positives and negatives, prudent discernment is required. Here are some tips on when to listen to it versus when to question it:

  • Trust reassuring intuitions, but question catastrophic thinking.
  • Believe motivations toward positive change, but scrutinize resistance to improvement.
  • Accept its honesty about real flaws, but don’t buy into exaggerations.
  • Follow its wisdom about people’s motivations, but verify any assumptions.
  • Listen to self-care advice, but review any rationalizations for avoidance.

Getting to know your inner voice’s typical tendencies can help you discern when to tune in versus when to be wary. Track its accuracy over time so you can evaluate its trustworthiness.

Strategies for Coping with an Overly Harsh Inner Critic

If your self-talk tends to be predominantly negative, there are ways to mitigate its impact:

  • Identify triggers for negative self-talk so you can counteract rather than automatically accept it.
  • Challenge distortions like catastrophizing or hyperbole in your inner voice when they arise.
  • Intentionally cultivate and listen to voices of self-compassion.
  • Limit consumption of media that promotes harsh self-judgment.
  • Practice thinking encouraging thoughts until they become habits that counter the critical voice.

You have some agency over the nature of your inner voice. With consistent effort, you can amplify its positive and wise aspects while decreasing the volume on unrelentingly negative self-talk.

Ways to Discern the Voice of Intuition from Random Thoughts

How can you differentiate helpful intuitive inner wisdom from random mental chatter? Here are some suggestions:

  • Intuitive insights often have a soothing, calm quality rather than anxious rumination.
  • Intuitions arise spontaneously rather than constant repetitive thoughts.
  • Wise inner guidance tends to encourage rather than condemn.
  • Intuition aligns with your deeply held values rather than fleeting impulses.
  • Genuine intuition provides nuanced perspective rather than black-and-white extremes.

Pay attention to the quality and tone of your thoughts. Anxiety-provoking mental rehearsals are unlikely to contain helpful wisdom. Likewise, compulsive repetition signals random obsession rather than meaningful insight. Reflect on the nature of your inner voice to better distinguish between fruitful intuition and unhelpful rumination.

The Healthiest Relationship with Your Inner Voice

Aim for a balanced relationship with the voice inside your head. Neither ignoring it completely nor blindly obeying it tends to end well. Instead, consider these principles for a healthy dynamic:

  • Listen to understand rather than react.
  • Thank the voice for sharing, even if you don’t agree.
  • Politely question the accuracy of extremely negative self-talk.
  • Check uncertain assumptions or intuitions against reality tests.
  • Determine if obeying inner resistance prevents growth.
  • Consider perspectives beyond what your inner voice claims.

You don’t have to follow the decrees of your inner voice – you can thoughtfully consider then decide which guidance to heed. Cultivate self-compassion for the aspects of your inner voice you’d rather not obey. A balanced relationship involves expressing gratitude for the voice while setting boundaries against unhealthy self-talk.

When to Seek Help

Most people experience occasional negative thoughts from their inner voice. But if you find your self-talk to be extremely hostile, persistent, and difficult to control, consider seeking professional support. Signs you may need help managing your inner voice include:

  • Suicidal ideation or self-harm commands.
  • Highly distorted negative thoughts about yourself.
  • An inner voice that feels alien or intolerable.
  • Inability to quiet constant harsh self-criticism.
  • Inner voice prevents you from everyday functioning.

A therapist can help identify the roots of persistent unhealthy inner voice patterns and equip you with coping strategies. Medication may help in some cases. You don’t have to keep struggling against an aggressive inner battle – support is available.


Your inner voice can offer both wisdom and folly. By understanding its pros and cons, learning to differentiate helpful intuition from unhelpful rumination, and cultivating greater self-compassion, you can develop a healthier relationship with that voice inside your head. Pay attention to its tone and accuracy. Seek support if your self-talk becomes highly destructive. With care and practice, you can benefit from your inner voice while gaining freedom from its most damaging tendencies.