Skip to Content

What should you avoid when mixing pancake batter?

Making perfect pancakes takes skill and know-how. While pancake batter seems simple, with ingredients like flour, baking powder, sugar, milk, eggs, and butter, there are some key things to avoid when mixing up this breakfast staple. Properly mixing pancake batter ensures light and fluffy results, while mistakes can lead to flat, dense, or rubbery pancakes. As a professional writer, in this article I will provide readers with important tips on what to avoid when making pancake batter, so you can achieve pancake perfection every time.

Overmixing the Batter

One of the most common mistakes people make when mixing pancake batter is overmixing. While you want to mix the wet and dry ingredients together thoroughly, overmixing leads to overdeveloped gluten in the flour. This results in tough, rubbery pancakes rather than light and fluffy ones.

Here are some tips to ensure you don’t overmix the batter:

– Mix wet and dry ingredients gently until just combined. Avoid vigorously beating or whisking the batter.

– Lumps in the batter are ok! Small lumps will sort themselves out when cooking.

– Don’t use a stand mixer to make pancake batter. The high-speed mixing develops too much gluten.

– Mix with a whisk, fork, or rubber spatula. Use a light hand when folding the ingredients together.

– Don’t keep mixing once the dry ingredients are moistened. It only takes about 10 gentle folds to properly combine pancake batter.

Using Too Much Liquid

Another mistake is adding too much liquid to pancake batter. This can make the batter too thin, resulting in flat pancakes that spread too much while cooking. The ideal pancake batter should be thick but still pourable.

Here are some tips for getting the liquid ratio right:

– Precisely measure ingredients rather than estimating.

– Start with less liquid called for in a recipe, then add more as needed.

– Buttermilk and whole milk tend to produce thicker batter than nonfat milk. Adjust the liquid accordingly.

– Allow batter to rest 5 minutes before cooking. Thicker batter will relax and thin out slightly.

– The batter should slowly drip off a spoon or spatula. If it’s too thin and runny, mix in a bit more flour.

Forgetting the Leavening Agent

Leavening agents like baking powder or baking soda are essential for light and fluffy pancakes. Without a leavening agent, your pancakes will be dense and flat.

Here are tips for incorporating leavening properly:

– Use baking powder or baking soda called for in the recipe.

– Make sure baking powder or soda is fresh and active. Old leavening won’t rise properly.

– Do not overmix once leavening is added, as this can deflate the batter.

– Allow batter to rest 5-10 minutes after mixing to allow leavening to work.

– For extra rise, you can separate wet and dry ingredients and mix baking soda into the wet. Then fold wet into dry.

– Do not use both baking soda and powder unless recipe specifies. Too much leavening causes overspread.

Using the Wrong Type of Flour

While all-purpose flour is most common for pancakes, using other types of flour improperly can ruin the texture.

Here are some flour tips:

– All-purpose flour provides the best texture. Do not substitute cake or bread flour.

– Whole wheat flour can work but may make dense pancakes. Mix with all-purpose.

– For fluffier pancakes, substitute up to 1/4 of the flour with cornstarch.

– Gluten-free flours usually require added leavening and xanthan gum to mimic all-purpose flour.

– Make sure to whisk flour thoroughly before using to aerate. Sifted flour makes lighter cakes.

– Weigh flour for accuracy. Measuring cups can pack down more flour than required.

Using Too Many Mix-Ins

While adding extra ingredients like chocolate chips, berries, or nuts can add exciting flavors to pancakes, too many mix-ins can ruin the batter.

Here are some tips for mix-ins:

– Nuts, chocolate, and dried fruit should equal no more than 1/4 cup per 2 cups of batter.

– Fresh berries and fruit should equal no more than 1 cup per 2 cups of batter.

– Avoid soft ingredients like bananas and juices which excessively thin batter.

– Coat sturdy mix-ins in flour to prevent sinking to the bottom.

– Add chunky mix-ins at the end once batter is mixed, and fold in gently by hand.

– Allow batter to rest 10 minutes after adding mix-ins to prevent sinking and streaking while cooking.

Not Letting the Batter Rest

Allowing pancake batter to rest 5-10 minutes before cooking allows the ingredients to fully hydrate and gives leavening agents time to produce gas for lift.

Here are some resting tips:

– Even quick batters improve after 5 minutes rest time.

– During rest, gluten relaxes, batter hydrates, and leavening agents react.

– For thicker batters or those with mix-ins, allow 10-15 minutes rest for optimal results.

– Cover batter as it rests to prevent drying out.

– The ideal rest time produces bubbly batter indicating lift and rise.

– Don’t overdo the rest time or batter can over-proof and collapse.

Using Old Baking Powder

Baking powder has a shelf life and loses its leavening power over time. Outdated baking powder can’t produce enough lift for light pancakes.

Here are tips for fresh baking powder:

– Store baking powder in a cool, dry place and tightly sealed. Humidity causes clumping.

– Baking powder’s effectiveness decreases after 6-12 months. Discard old powder.

– Do not use baking powder that smells like chlorine, which indicates expired powder.

– Double acting powder is more stable. Avoid single acting baking powder.

– Test viability by placing 1 teaspoon powder in hot water. Active powder fizzes rapidly.

– Improperly stored baking powder can lump up. Resift lumpy powder before using.


Avoiding these common pancake batter pitfalls will ensure your pancakes turn out with the perfect tender, fluffy texture every time. Precisely measuring ingredients, avoiding overmixing, allowing batter to rest, and using fresh leavening agents are keys to pancake success. With this pancake batter know-how, you’ll be flipping perfect cakes at home in no time.